Monday, January 31, 2005

And another... | by Jay

From the Boston Herald:
"Charlie just has a mind for the game,'' said second-year center Dan Koppen, a fifth-round draft pick out of Boston College who's thrived under Weis since taking over for an injured Damien Woody last season. "He puts the preparation in each and every week. He really has an idea of what the defenses are going to do against him, and he's able to call plays.''

Adaptability and diversity have been two hallmarks of Weis' offense. Those two attributes were on display to their fullest in the Patriots' two playoff victories this month. While the defense deservedly received plenty of credit for holding Peyton Manning and the explosive Colts to a mere field goal in the divisional round, the offense deserves just as much for the way it chewed up the clock with Corey Dillon.

Last week, Weis used a bombs-away approach in the first half to streak to an insurmountable lead against the Steelers, who boasted the best defense in the NFL.

"We go out there and figure out 'How can we beat this team?' not based on what our offense is but based on what our best chance is of beating them is,'' tight end Christian Fauria said.

"If it makes sense for us to work towards a team's strengths, we'll do that. If it makes sense to work away from their strengths, we'll do that. Every week is a different game plan, and every week, depending on what the defense is, we decide whether it's best to run at their best players or weakest players. It changes every week.''

Weis' offense has kept everyone involved. Six players had at least 25 catches in the regular season and 10 had at least 10 grabs. That kind of distribution might keep some capable players from reaching Pro Bowl numbers, but it also lets players know that nobody's just along for the ride.

Sunday, January 30, 2005

Feeling Super. Thanks for asking. | by Jay

One byproduct of Super Bowl week is the glut of articles sifting through every aspect of the upcoming bout, no matter how trivial (in the past week I've read about Freddie Mitchell's new country music album, the dearth of limousines in Jacksonville, and the ongoing growth of Patriots superfan JJ Feigenbaum's lucky beard). So it's no surprise to see some Charlie Weis stories trickling in amidst the filler.

J.A. Adande of the LA Times keeps the drumbeat of fluff going with this short profile, which is notable only because it's the first time I've seen Rob Ianello quoted in an ND story. But in keeping with the spirit of super-intense, Super Week scrutiny, I pass it on to you. Just doing my part to prove Boyle's Law of Thermodynamics (gas expands to fill a vacuum).

Saturday, January 29, 2005

quick postscript | by Jay

Actually, I will point out one particular piece of new info from the previous article.

Apparently, if the NCAA expands to a 12-game season, ND will add an annual game at the Meadowlands, in an effort to "revitalize" east coast interest in the Irish and hopefully give a boost to recruiting from the area. Sounds like a neat idea, and I'm curious to see who they'll line up for the game (I suppose Army and Navy will be in the rotation). Recruiting-wise, it'd probably be a little more productive than our annual west coast jag. The northeast has always been a solid source of Irish talent, but it's been a while since we've really been plugged-in.

ND + Meadowlands + Joisey native Charlie Weis = fuhggeddaboutit.

"It's like a new Notre Dame" | by Jay

Arthur Staple of Newsday just put together such a comprehensive and enlightening summary of the new dawn at ND that trying to pull out the pertinent snippets is pretty much an impossible task. So instead, I'll just offer up the whole thing. Enjoy.



Golden Dome Shines Again

After one of the worst periods in its history, there is a feeling of excitement at Notre Dame


SOUTH BEND, Ind. -- D.J. Hord had been to Baton Rouge. He'd been to Madison. He'd been wooed and wowed by the facilities and the prospect of catching passes for LSU or Wisconsin, two elite schools using all their resources to get a commitment from a top 100 high school wide receiver.

Hord came here next, to the most hallowed ground in college football. Touchdown Jesus stood tall over Notre Dame Stadium. The Golden Dome glinted in the winter sun. The tradition called out, as it has to thousands of high school football players in the last century.

But Hord looked a little closer. That stadium? Not much to look at, really. And the part about walking -- in pads, helmets and jerseys -- from the stadium locker rooms to the practice fields a quarter-mile away ... This is the greatest program ever?

"I was shocked, actually," said Hord, a 6-1, 180-pound senior at Kansas City's Rockhurst High. "To be there, with all the greatness of the history, and see that the facilities weren't up to par with all the other big schools ... It was a shock."

Hord wasn't the first recruit to be stunned. Notre Dame's ignominious display of the past two months -- firing Tyrone Willingham, enduring the resulting cries of racism, failing to get then-Utah coach Urban Meyer into the fold -- diminished the stature of the program. Nevertheless, Hord did give an oral commitment to the Fighting Irish after that visit earlier this month.

He found three reasons to be optimistic about the future. They are the same reasons the Notre Dame family is so giddy, a surprising turn of events coming on the heels of one of the most humiliating periods in school history.

The first thing that impressed Hord is that those outdated facilities are about to get an upgrade: The 95,000-square-foot, $22-million Guglielmino Center will open in June. New coach Charlie Weis called it a major step forward for Notre Dame recruiting.

"No longer will you just have to sell the name. You'll have the school, the name and a facility that will be second to none," Weis said. "When players walk in, they'll say, 'Whoa.' That's what it's going to be when they walk in there: It's going to be a 'Whoa.'"

The second piece is Weis himself. The offensive coordinator of the New England Patriots is busy preparing for a third Super Bowl in four years, so he barely has had time to attack his new job. But Notre Dame might have accidentally helped point itself in the right direction by hiring the New Jersey native after the firing of Willingham, the misfire on Meyer and a few interviews that went nowhere. Weis, a disciple of Bill Parcells and Bill Belichick, has guided some of the top offenses in the NFL for the past decade.

Last, but hardly least, is the feverish fan base that athletic director Kevin White calls "the national parish." White, an Amityville native, said calls for Notre Dame to join a conference "have been around since the Rockne days." Through the lean years since Lou Holtz left as coach in 1996, the calls have become louder. But White said the school never has been more committed to playing -- and recruiting -- on a national scale and as an independent.

If the NCAA votes in April to go to a 12-game schedule, as is expected, Notre Dame plans to add a yearly date at the Meadowlands to revitalize the East Coast football community that once provided the Irish its talent base.

"The new staff, the new facilities ... It's like a new Notre Dame," Hord said. "I can't wait to be a part of it."

White has a blueprint of the Guglielmino Center in his office. He's been working to make the building a reality since he arrived on March 13, 2000. "He probably had better facilities at Central Michigan," one Notre Dame administrator said of White's days as a track coach in the 1970s.

White pointed out that he was at Central Michigan the same time as Willingham, who was coaching the secondary. "He's a friend" is among the few thoughts White offers on the Willingham debacle. He and outgoing university president Rev. Edward Malloy voted against the firing but were overruled by incoming Notre Dame president Rev. John Jenkins and three Board of Trustees members, led by Morgan Stanley CEO Philip Purcell.

"Any time you go through a staff transition, it's painful," White said. The ensuing debate about the racial implications of firing Notre Dame's only black head coach brought more pain, and layered onto the disgruntlement expressed by thousands of alumni who turned on NBC every Saturday and watched a disjointed offense get pounded from coast to coast.

"The level of interest and passion in this program is unquantifiable," White said. "It's what makes Notre Dame Notre Dame."

White knew what his program needed even after Meyer, a former Notre Dame assistant, decided the hubbub wasn't worth returning for. "It became," White said, "an opportunity for us to reinvent ourselves. We have a wonderful history and tradition that has served us very well for, oh, about 114 years in college football. But it's very, very important that we stay current. Any opportunity you have to get better, you do it."

Turning to a college coaching lifer did not seem the answer, even as time dwindled through December to an Insight Bowl date with Oregon State (a 38-21 loss, the Irish's seventh straight loss in a bowl game). In Weis, who signed a six-year, $12-million contract, White found fresh blood in a Notre Dame alum (class of 1978) and someone who could bring innovation to the field.

In six weeks, Weis has been at the school for perhaps five days total. He's turned into the personification of the old Army ads, doing more before 9 a.m. (and after midnight) than most people do all day. And his double duty, running the Patriots' offense while calling recruits and current Irish players at night, has impressed everyone.

"He's exceeded our expectations so far, I'd say," White said.

That started with his coaching staff. Weis, whose work with Patriots quarterback Tom Brady is an ongoing success story, never had met David Cutcliffe, who also helped produce one of the best quarterbacks in the NFL. Cutcliffe was offensive coordinator at Tennessee when Peyton Manning was learning the ropes; he also was head coach at Mississippi when Eli Manning was there. So Weis, lacking the time for a major search, called Cut.cliffe and hired him just before New Year's Day without ever actually meeting him.

Weis has three former head coaches on his staff, tantamount to heresy in the coaching world: You never hire someone who could just step right in for you. "I'd rather get the best people available, regardless of experience," said Weis, whose staff also includes former Cincinnati coach Rick Minter as defensive coordinator (his job at Notre Dame from 1992-93) and former Georgia Tech head coach Bill Lewis as assistant head coach.

"When you get three guys with that ability to come and join your staff, if you don't get them, you're the one making the mistake," Weis said.

"He's not coming in here to do well and make the move somewhere else," Cutcliffe said. "This is Notre Dame."

The next step for Weis was recruiting. National signing day is Wednesday. Not only did Weis and his staff have to establish relationships with high school coaches and athletes who had been recruited for months by other schools, they had to try to maintain commitments from those who had wanted to play for Willingham and turned away.

Weis has lost a few. Wide receiver David Nelson of Texas wanted to sit down with Weis before re-committing. The AFC Championship Game win by the Patriots made that impossible, and Nelson is going to join Meyer in Florida. But Weis has kept a few players, mostly skill guys.

"I'd say this could end up working out great for me," said Evan Sharpley, a quarterback from Marshall, Mich., who committed in July. "He's been so successful at the pro level and he's brought in such a good staff, it's hard not to be excited."

"That Super Bowl ring is huge!" said Ray Herring, a safety from Melbourne, Fla. "It doesn't even look real."

For better or worse, that is what recruits want: a chance to make their NFL dreams more real. Brady Quinn is the incumbent quarterback, a sophomore who endured a pair of 6-5 seasons but still can say he attends one of the top academic institutions in the land.

"When you make the decision to come here," he said, "it's a life-altering experience. Playing football is one thing, but it's joining a network of alumni that's better than just about anyplace else."

Still, as White said, "The goal is to play on Sunday." That's what sells blue-chippers, not Rockne and Parseghian and Holtz. It's why, in addition to the experienced staff he's hired, Weis will have Heis.man Trophy winner and future NFL Hall of Famer Tim Brown on staff the minute Brown hangs it up in the pros.

"We've been able to recruit a very good cut of student-athletes," White said, "but I'll say we have to do a better job of identifying the four, five high-end recruits, the difference-makers. In football, you need the difference-makers."

Hord is the only difference-maker in the fold for this year's recruiting class, which is ranked in the 20s among Division I schools by ESPN and Rivals.com. But "The Gug," as the training facility has been dubbed, will be open by June. Weis might have another Super Bowl ring to show off as he shakes the hand of a wide-eyed 17-year-old who can run a 4.5 in the 40. And the collective minds of Weis and his staff might excite plenty who watch on Saturday.

The national parish, said White, "has never been more galvanized."

"It's all about winning," said Hord, wise beyond his years. "And Notre Dame is willing to do whatever it takes to win."

Friday, January 28, 2005

A Tale of Two Kiddies | by Dylan

It was the best of times, it was the blurst of times….or something.

Following up a bit on Teds’ post (at least tangentially), the past week provided one of those “agony and ecstasy” dichotomies for ND fans who follow the increasingly Brechtian spectacle of the closing of the recruiting period. Following the news was like reading the bastard child of BGI and Highlights, with the roles of Goofus and Gallant being played by David Nelson and Ray Herring. Hopefully, the story will serve as a signpost for the turning of the tide in the Willingham-to-Weis transition, one on which we will look back with bumfuzzlement.

Nelson, of the now famous commitus interruptus and the Goofus of our story, will be forever enshrined as the embodiment of the “Ty Willingham recruit,” the player who wanted to play for the man, not the school. The type of player who bought the false premise that one’s success as a “man” mitigated one’s lack of gridiron achievement. Teds summed this up exceptionally well down below (and considerably more generously than I would have, eschewing the encouragement I would have offered to Mr. Nelson to perform certain unnatural and physically impossible acts upon himself after his decision that, if Charlie would not play James Lipton to his Nick Cage, he would make a cuckold of ND and pledge his precious flower to Pope Urban the Turd), and I’m content to let that speak for itself. I will stay above the fray.

Ray Herring has spent the past two weeks being everything that a Notre Dame fan could want. (Be sure to read his latest diary entry here.) His enthusiasm for the school, the fans, the team, and every word in the English language that starts with an “N” or a “D” has been infectious. Next, I expect an entry in his diary praising the culinary perfection of the South Dining Hall, the soaring and inspirational architecture of Flanner, and the sweet, sweet smell of ethanol. Assuming that Ray is the real deal (and there is absolutely no reason to assume otherwise), we may be looking at the proto-recruit for the reborn football program. What the program has lacked, and this is directly attributable to Willingham and his belligerently clueless predecessor, is kids who come to Notre Dame because they want to play for Notre Dame. Herring, in case you missed it, is stupendously, fantastically, tremendously, reconculously excited, not just to have made the decision to come to Notre Dame, but to be a part of it. He, a senior in high school, understands what Notre Dame means better than either of the two previous stewards of the House that Rock Built. Is he too good to be true? Who knows. But one thing is for certain, I would rather have a team of Ray Herrings (especially on a team coached by Charlie Weis) than a team of David Nelsons. Nelson is a very gifted football player, but Herring seems to be a winner of the New England Patriots variety. He doesn’t seem to see success as his birthright, as do many of today’s pampered, coddled student-athletes; but as a goal which requires discipline, work, and faith, and one which, once attained, bears sweeter fruit as a result.

Welcome to the family, Ray. Keep calling your prospective classmates. Next August, share your insight and your enthusiasm with them. Be their leader. Tell them where you want to take them. I have little doubt they’ll follow.

Battle report | by Jay

From the Northwest Indiana Times, another dispatch from the recruiting front lines.

Defensive line recruit Pat Kuntz out of Indianapolis talks about the touch-and-go nature of the coaching transition, how he almost went elsewhere ("If he would have called a day later, I wouldn't have gone to Notre Dame"), and what ultimately sold him on ND.

Also a couple of good quotes from DJ Hord.
Another Irish recruit, wide receiver D.J. Hord of Kansas City, Mo., believes Weis' credentials will help the school's recruiting efforts as next Tuesday national signing date draws nearer.

"I really think what he's doing right now will play a role,'' Hord said. "With them playing for a Super Bowl title again, it shows that he's a coach who can win consistently. To me, his offense is outstanding, very impressive.

"It gets you excited about playing for him. I'm anxious to get up there, get to work and learn his system as quickly as possible.''
And a final note from Allen Wallace of SuperPrep magazine, on the recruiting benefits of playing in the Superbowl:
"It's basically all he has to sell right now, but that's a lot,'' Wallace said. "The fact that the man recruiting you can move the ball against any defense in the NFL, is a huge plus. Players thinking your coach, with his Xs and Os, can outscheme the opposition, I think that gives any team an enormous advantage. I think it would be a very big factor for any recruit to consider before he decides for or against playing at Notre Dame.''
You sort of wish David Nelson had connected the dots as Wallace suggests; instead, Nelson complained about the very thing that makes Weis preeminent. (Sour grapes, I know.)

The Gag Order | by Teds

David Nelson, a wide receiver recruit Notre Dame had been pursuing in the current campaign, cast his fate with the Florida Gators during a visit to Gainesville last weekend. As a highly-ranked prospect who had been committed to former ND coach Tyrone Willingham prior to his dismissal, Nelson had been the source of some consternation among Irish fans.

(The quicker ones among you may notice that I mentioned Willingham specifically in association with Nelson, not the University of Notre Dame as a whole. There's a reason for that.)

It's not unprecedented for a prep prospect to change his commitment midstream after a coach has been replaced. Nor is it all that unusual for a high school player to sign on with the coaching staff who gives him the most and best attention, as Nelson admitted regarding his pledge to Urban Meyer and the Gators. Most ND fans didn't hold it against fellow ex-Willingham commit Lawrence Wilson when his interest in the Irish was rekindled after seven Notre Dame assistants dropped by to visit at his Akron-area school and home recently. Whether we openly admit it or not, most followers realize that attention in one form or another pays when it comes to recruiting.

At the same time, the internet age has transformed recruiting into big business and made household names of kids who haven't yet picked out prom tuxedos. Recruiting services regularly hound these young men for scraps of new information that might provide some insight as to their college destination for the thousands of sick twists (yo!) who consider such things worth obsessing over. From the mouths of babes...come what is often accepted as gospel nowadays.

One of the problems with that is the fact that the NCAA does not allow college coaches to discuss recruits by name during the process. So although the players in question can and often do provide gory, blow-by-blow accounts of their dealings with different suitors which are naturally subjective and occassionally shy on certain details, there's no outlet for a counterpoint from coaches and schools on the other end of the equation. As a result, what we're left with -- at least on the record -- is a one-sided conversation, or, if you prefer, "He said, [inaudible]".

So when Nelson declares, "For my dad to be comfortable sending me somewhere, he needed to be able to look a head coach in the eyes", there's a decent chance that he's sincere in his remarks. But there's also the possibility that Nelson is merely trolling for an excuse, something concrete to tell the reporters that will make his change of heart more understandable and palatable.

Admittedly possessing no special insight, I suspect that if Weis had the opportunity to visit with Nelson and his family face to face, the meeting would have done nothing more than forced the player to come up with a different and more outrageous reason to sign his letter of intent with a different school. Maybe something along the lines of: "My folks really needed to see Coach Weis don the San Diego Chicken mascot costume and do the Cabbage Patch to feel comfortable about his intentions and the security of my athletic and scholastic future".

(Then again, who knows? I only used this as an example because it's how I arrange most of my dates. Although that Chicken head can get a bit stuffy, so truth be told, I allow some of the more fetching girls to do their business without it. But I digress.)

Whatever the case, the NCAA's gag order gives these 16-18 year-old kids the simultaneous freedom and burden of shouldering the load as the designated mouthpiece in documenting the various relationships they develop with college coaching staffs, only one of which will ultimately come to fruition. Certainly, a recruit could just plead the fifth, but a "no comment" will often accomplish little more than stoking the fires of curiousity and leading to further badgering of the witness.

To be clear, I'm not looking for some sort of change in the restriction placed on these schools and their employees with respect to discussion of prospective players by name. As with any business which interviews candidates for employ and turns down some while also being rejected by others, it's poor form to openly discuss the details of the process. What I would ask is that those who follow the recruiting game closely and judge schools and coaches based on their success or failure in luring prized prospects to sign on their dotted line might take the postmortem comments of said prospects with a grain of salt.

Some will appear to change their priorities as the process unfolds, while others will completely fabricate reasons for choosing one school or declining the advances of another. Many will say that education matters but few will mean it, and certain ones who purportedly consider quality schooling a factor will make the kind of decision that leaves observers wondering if they actually grasp the definition of the term. Some will not be completely forthright about the schools that sincerely pursued them, and a few might even declare a "choice" of, say, BC when other options didn't actually exist. And all will lie like dogs about their height, weight and 40-yard dash times.

But this has all become an accepted part of the dance. We come to expect a certain amount of half-truths and gorilla dust. These teenaged kids have been all but strapped to a television camera, microphone or journalist's keyboard, and it's a difficult age for even the most well-adjusted among them to handle that sort of exposure with winning grace and brutal honesty. Cripes, it's hard enough for people twice that age.

You don't have to hate the game, but recognize the player for the possibility that his best interests might not neatly align with the unvarnished truth.

Thursday, January 27, 2005

Are You Experienced? | by Pat

With the arrival of a new coaching staff, as the cliché goes, everyone starts from scratch. Throw out the old depth charts and wipe the slate clean, because every player, no matter his experience, is going to be learning a new system and competing for a spot in the starting lineup.

But the reality is that nothing in practice nor read in the playbook can prepare a player for that moment when he steps onto the field, surrounded by tens of thousands of screaming fans. Experience is important. And while the 2004 season just ended 30 days ago, it's never too early to look forward to 2005.

A few days ago, Lou Somogyi of Blue and Gold Illustrated posted an article with the playing times of each player from the 2004 season. Some quick crunching of the numbers shows that while the Notre Dame offense will return virtually intact, the defense will have large holes in experience at multiple positions. Obviously the new coaching staff might make position changes, and young players could surprise and beat out returning veterans. But unlike a stock market disclaimer, past perfomance is a strong indicator of future results when it comes to playing time.

Here's a quick breakdown of each position and a percentage of minutes played in 2004 at that position by players returning in 2005.

Overall, 89% of the offense is coming back, while only 36% of the defense will return.



Quarterback - 95.5%
The image “http://espn.starwave.com/media/ncf/2003/0926/photo/a_quinn_i.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.This is a pretty obvious stat as everyone knows that Brady Quinn is returning for his junior year. But this stat is a bit deceiving in that pretty much all of that 95.5% is Quinn's playing time himself. The inability to put many teams away early last season meant that Quinn usually played the entire game and our backups did not receive much playing time. In fact, the only other returning quarterback who saw time in 2004, David Wolke, played a mere 2 minutes out of the 374 minutes that a Notre Dame quarterback was on the field. So while the returning experience level at quarterback is high, the depth of that experience is not.

Quarterback '04 Minutes
Quinn 356
Dillingham 16
Wolke 2
Total 374
Returning 358
Difference (16.00)
Return Pct. 96%


Running Back - 67.6%
The bulk of the carries last year were split between Ryan Grant and Darius Walker. Grant has graduated and is the only starter on the offense that will not return in 2005. However, Walker had more carries and minutes played last year than Grant so Darius will hardly be a novice when he steps on the field as the starting running back at Heinz Field next September. However, the same depth concerns at quarterback apply here. While Walker proved durable last year, it is unrealistic to expect him to be able to carry the complete load next year. Marcus Wilson was a pleasant surprise last season in backup work and that should continue next year, but other running backs Travis Thomas, Jeff Jenkins, and Justin Hoskins only combined 28 minutes of playing time last season. At fullback, Rashon Powers-Neal returns but behind him Ashley McConnell has not seen the field yet.

Running Back 04 Minutes
Walker 150
Grant 128
Powers-Neal 119
Wilson 46
Schmidt 40
T. Thomas 21
Jenkins 7
Schiccatano 4
Hoskins 3
Total 518
Returning 390
Difference (128.00)
Return Pct. 68%


Offensive Line - 99.1%
Suffice it to say that Notre Dame will have one of the most veteran offensive lines in college football next year. Not only will all five starters return, but so will all of the second team players. This position should be a strength next year and a source of team leadership. Ryan Harris, Dan Stevenson, Bob Morton, and Mark LeVoir will be marking their third year in the starting rotation at offensive line while John Sullivan returns for his second. Incidentally, John Sullivan came into last season with no playing experience and logged the most minutes of any Irish player.

Offensive Line '04 Minutes
Sullivan 368
LeVoir 365
Harris 363
Stevenson 348
Morton 310
Santucci 81
Ryan 11
Mattes 8
Raridon 8
Thompson 7
Giles 6
Mitchell 4
Minutes 1879
Returning 1862
Difference (17)
Return Pct. 99%


The image “http://graphics.fansonly.com/photos/schools/nd/galleries/m-footbl-110803/fansonly_INND101_588611408112003-lg.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.Wide Receiver - 90.2%
Again, every starter returns and the only player who saw meaningful time that will not return is Carlyle Holiday. However, Matt Shelton's recent ACL injury puts a question mark about when and how he will be able to return to the field. Rhema McKnight and Maurice Stovall will make their final appearance in a Notre Dame uniform and my opinion is that they will stand to be the biggest beneficiaries of Charlie Weis' new offense. Surprising, to me at least, was that Jeff Samardzija was second only to Rhema McKnight in playing time last season at wide receiver. He should pick up where he left off in the Insight.com Bowl and round out a deep receiving corp.

Receiver '04 Minutes
McKnight 219
Samardzija 166
Shelton 160
Stovall 131
Holiday 79
Anastasio 42
Vaughn 10
Minutes 807
Returning 728
Difference (79.00)
Return Pct. 90%


Tight End - 71.1%
Notre Dame loses quality contributors Billy Palmer, Jerome Collins, and Jared Clark, but fans are excited about seeing Anthony Fasano return. Marcus Freeman and John Carlson also played well last season and that will result in yet another deep and experienced offensive position in 2005.

Tight End 04 Minutes
Fasano 269
Palmer 109
Freeman 76
Collins 32
Carlson 30
Clark 13
Minutes 529
Returning 375
Difference (154.00)
Return Pct. 71%




Now to the other side of the ball, where the percentages are lower and the expectations are, by necessity, higher.

Defensive Line - 42.6%
The image “http://media.collegepublisher.com/media/paper660/stills/l142hk2a.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.As with every position on defense, the top two players in terms of minutes played at defensive line will not return in 2005. Those names on the defensive line are Greg Pauly and Justin Tuck, who became the first defensive player to declare for the NFL Draft with remaining eligibility since Brock Williams in 2001. Kyle Budinscak, a co-starter for much of the 2004 season will also graduate. Derek Landri is the returning lineman with the most playing experience in 2004 and will team with Victor Abirimiri, Trevor Laws, Brian Beidatsch, Chris Frome, and Travis Leitko to reload the Irish defensive line. Dwight Stephenson Jr, Justin Brown, Ronald Talley, and Brandon Nicolas did not see the field in 2004, but could make contributions in 2005.

Defensive Line '04 Minutes
Pauly 266
Tuck 261
Landri 242
Budinscak 217
Abiamiri 194
Laws 122
Beidatsch 33
Frome 27
Leitko 5
Minutes 1367
Returning 623
Difference (744.00)
Return Pct. 43%


Linebacker - 29.4%
With the graduation of Mike Gooslby and Derek Curry, Brandon Hoyte is the only remaining returning starter and the percentage reflects that. Corey Mays also played meaningful mintues, but the rest of the returning linebackers are going to be very short on experience. The purpose of this post isn't to guess who will play where next year, but new names and faces will keep fans flipping through the media guide early and often next year as names like Mitchell Thomas, Joe Brockington, Nick Borseti, Abdel Banda, Maurice Crum Jr., Anthony Vernaglia (just going by und.com roster listings here folks) and the incoming freshman all fight for a starting spot.

Linebacker '04 Minutes
Curry 328
Goolsby 298
Hoyte 199
Mays 47
M. Thomas 9
Brockington 4
Borseti 3
Minutes 888
Returning 262
Difference (626.00)
Return Pct. 30%


Defensive Backs - 33%
This position will undoubtedly be a favorite of Depth Chart Engineers in the off-season. I didn't break down the numbers into cornerbacks and safeties precisely for this reason. The field is wide open and it's likely that position changes will affect this position more than any other. The only returning starter is Tom Zbikowski, although Mike Richardson logged quality minutes at cornerback. Like at linebacker, there are plenty of names but little to no returning experience. In fact, if you take Zbikowski out of the equation, the percentage of returning minutes played drops to a little under 12%. Fans saw glimpses of Ambrose Wooden, Freddie Parish IV, and Chinedum Nduwke last season and the young talent does give hope for the future. But only time will tell how they mix in with other players like Lionel Bolen, Jake Carney, Leo Ferrine, Terrail Lambert, LaBrose Hedgemon, Junior Jabbie, Tregg Duerson, and whatever incoming freshman end up in the defensive backfield.

Defensive Back '04 Minutes
Ellick 343
Burrell 336
Zbikowski 331
Jackson 270
Richardson 134
Campbell 86
Parish 27
Ndukwe 13
Wooden 7
Bolen 2
Carney 1
Minutes 1550
Returning 515
Difference (1035.00)
Return Pct. 33%


Wednesday, January 26, 2005

Ready for my close-up | by Jay

On Slate.com, Stephen Rodrick mourns the death of traditional sports writing, and fingers the rise of sports TV outlets like ESPN and the ensuing multitasking by print columnists as the culprits. It's a solid rant against the watering-down of sports commentary, and it's definitely worth a read. He particularly skewers Stephen A. Smith, much to my delight.

Where have you gone, Jim Murray? A sound-bite nation turns its lonely eyes to you.

Breaking up the Flying Wedge | by Jay

In researching the previous post, I came upon a neat history of the NCAA.

Did you know that the NCAA was formed mainly in response to the brutality and violence of early-century football? It's true. You could look it up.



"As more schools picked up the game and the rules developed over time, football became a body-slinging battle that often resulted in severe injuries. There was no forward pass, no neutral zone between teams and no limit to how few players could be on the line at once.

The image “http://www.hornetfootball.org/images/history/early_football.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors."Hurdle plays" were permitted, allowing teams to literally pick up and launch their ball carrier over the opposing line. Mass-momentum plays, whereby the runner is protected by a moving "V" or a "flying wedge" of players, gained popularity as a way to advance the ball, but they also increased the game's violence as linemen were permitted to do almost anything to run over the opposition.

There were no helmets, mouthpieces or face guards, and the few primitive pads that existed were of little benefit to the athlete.

As football's critics got louder, it was obvious that there was need for reform. State legislatures debated making it illegal and several colleges and universities banned the sport, but the loosely formed national football rules committee only offered up a few changes to the game.

"To make matters worse," wrote football historian Col. A. M. Weyland, "there was no authoritative body that could take the necessary action."

The 1905 college football season produced 18 deaths and 149 serious injuries, leading those in higher education to question the game's place on their campuses.

"One human life is too big a price for all the games of the season," said James Roscoe Day, chancellor of Syracuse University.

The game might have died that year had it not been for the nation's chief executive officer, President Theodore Roosevelt, a Harvard man, football fan and former student-athlete. On October 9, 1905, before the bloody season had even finished, Roosevelt called representatives of Harvard, Yale and Princeton to the White House to discuss the game's future. Roosevelt was clear: Reform the game or it will be outlawed, perhaps even by an Executive Order of the President himself.

After hearing of the President's concerns, the existing rules committee made some changes to the game, but there was still no national athletics organization with the power to force the committee to completely reform football.

Then Henry M. MacCracken, the chancellor of New York University, took it upon himself to call a meeting of football-playing institutions of higher education. Thirteen attended that first meeting in New York City on December 9, 1905, and the schools decided to reform the game and meet again, on December 28. At that meeting, 62 schools are represented.

Capt. Palmer E. Pierce of the U.S. Military Academy suggested creating a formal association, the National Intercollegiate Football Conference. Representatives from the other schools agreed with the idea, but decided to leave out the word "football," thus creating the Intercollegiate Athletic Association of the United States (IAAUS).

The delegates also created a new IAAUS football rules committee and invited the old football rules committee to participate, which they eventually agreed to do. What was known as the "amalgamated" committee made many changes to the game, including approving the forward pass, prohibiting hurdling and mass-momentum plays (by requiring at least six men on the offensive line), and increasing first-down yardage to 10 yards. The game was saved, and by the issuing of a formal constitution and bylaws on March 31, 1906, the Association -- still the IAAUS for another four years -- was created."

the Graduate(s) | by Jay

It didn't seem to generate a lot of discussion at the time, but a couple of weeks ago the NCAA released some new standards for academic performance for athletes at Division 1 schools. Under the new guidelines, college sports teams must stay on track to graduate at least 50 percent of their student-athletes to avoid the risk of losing scholarships for a year, under a plan approved by the NCAA Division I Board of Directors.

The brickbat here seems to be something called a contemporaneous penalty, which means that when one of your players flunks out, leaves, or otherwise fails to graduate, your school may not re-award his/her scholarship a new student-athlete. This restriction lasts for one year. (For a lengthier explanation of the penalty system, take a look here.)

A second component to the new rules involves losing scholarships if your across-the-program grades aren't good enough. A new scoring system will go into place, a 1,000-point scale that measures your overall academic achievement. The Chronicle of Higher Education explained it in an article last Friday:

The 1,000-scale score equates to a percentage: 925 means that a team received 92.5 percent of all possible points.

Each scholarship athlete on a team earns two points per term by returning to college and passing enough classes to remain eligible for sports, according to another complex formula. Athletes who return to college but do not pass enough courses to be eligible earn one point, and those who flunk out altogether earn none.

Take a football team with 80 scholarship athletes at a college with two semesters. Assume, however implausibly, that all the athletes pass their courses for the fall semester. But 10 players decide in February to leave college immediately. Five more do not pass enough courses in the spring to remain eligible, but return to college anyway.

The team can score a maximum of 320 points (two points per athlete per semester). The players who leave cost the team 20 points; those who fail their courses cost five points. So the team has 295 points, or 92.2 percent of 320. Thus, its final score is 922.

Because the score falls below the threshold of 925, the team faces the loss of 10 scholarships for the next year.

But the NCAA decided to cap the number of scholarships teams can lose at 10 percent of the maximum they may award. Football teams are permitted 85 grants, so this team would lose the maximum of 9.

The NCAA estimates that 30 percent of Division I football teams would have lost scholarships, based on 2003-4 data, under the new plan. A quarter of baseball teams and 20 percent of basketball teams also would have been punished.

Now, the NCAA is nothing if not a rule-making body, but as far as I can tell, this is the first time the NCAA has tied actual graduation rates to athletic incentives and penalties. It's quite a bold step, since for the first time it encumbers the school with the responsibility of not just qualifying kids and keeping them in class, but actually sending them off into the world with a diploma when their athletic usefulness has expired.

So, a couple of thoughts on all this.

First of all...50% graduation rate? Well, I'm blown away -- talk about setting the bar high.
Fifty percent. Wow. Except maybe in gambling, or dating (or maybe voter turnout), in what other area of life is 50% anywhere near a successful outcome? Yet, for Division 1 sports, fifty percent is considered an acceptable rate of success.

In fact, it's not just acceptable...for some programs, it's a major improvement. Check out the sub-50% graduation rates of these major college football programs (based on 2003 stats, from an exhaustive analysis by Stanford's TheBootleg.com):


Miami49%
Florida St.49%
Michigan46%
Florida44%
Colorado43%
Ohio State41%
Tennessee41%
LSU40%
Georgia Tech39%
Texas38%
Oklahoma33%

(By the way, these numbers can fluctuate wildly from year to year. Texas, because of a dismal performance by the most recent class, saw its four-class grad rate drop from 50% to 38% in a single season.)

So fifty percent, a really rather modest goal, would nonetheless be a triumph for the likes of Oklahoma. It's really almost unbelievable that only a third of the guys on your football team are going to graduate, but there it is. These football factories needed a healthy dose of healing shame, and the new rules are a good step in the right direction.

And yet, you know they're going to find a way around it, somehow. The risks of not graduating your players has just dramatically increased, and your livelihood and identity as a "football school" hangs in the balance, so you've got to make it work. The obvious recourse, it seems to me, is going to be to simply push the kids through, increasing the number of "gut" classes and greasing the wheels of academia to keep the machine humming along. I'm sure it's the cynic in me thinking this way, but looking at the history of recruiting -- an area where violations have been piling up for years, despite any NCAA sanctions -- you have to realize that where there's a will, there's a way.

So will these new rules really have any teeth? And will the end result be simply a devaluing of the diploma itself, turning it into a meaningless piece of puffery worth no more than the paper it's printed on? NCAA czar Myles Brand actually weighed in on this very argument, saying it's an insult to the faculty who create the classes and the academic environment. "We have to ferret out the fraud", says Brand. Yet, short of installing a truly independent, objective NCAA compliance officer at each school, I'm not sure how you can accomplish this.

A few years back there was a five-part series in the Chicago Tribune on the uneasy relationship between higher education and athletics, and while the NCAA landscape has evolved somewhat since
then, the article still gives a glimpse of how big-time programs manage to operate under the umbrella of academia:

One Midwest football coach said as much: "There are no level playing fields in this academic stuff. Michigan is a big-time institution, and they find a way to hide their athletes. It doesn't take a genius to know what's going on. I can show you the transcripts of the kind of kids they're getting into Michigan. They're going through the back door."

"Did I put (marginal students) into sports management? Yeah, I put them there," said Frieder, now the coach at Arizona State. "They're not going to make it at Michigan in the school of business. All my kids on my good teams went through sports management. If you want those kind of kids, you have to have an avenue for them."

But at the same time, yes, it is a place where Michigan houses several of its student-athletes, some of them who are academically marginal. There are suggestions from sports management's own faculty that some Michigan athletes are directed into the program as a way of surviving in a tough academic climate. In its course curriculum, sports management has "remedial" math and study skills classes that faculty members say are in place for marginal student-athletes.
It's a bit of folly to think that by simple decree, the NCAA can somehow invoke the Platonic ideal of "student-athlete" and suddenly transform these football factories into institutions that truly serve the interests of the students, but it's good that they're trying, and it's got to be done.

And there also needs to be a stark realization that in the grand scheme of things, college isn't for everyone. On some level, the NCAA code of rules is like Frankenstein's monster, cobbled together from spare parts and held together by the thinnest of sinews, an unnatural creature always one step away from falling to pieces. Each year, it seems, new regulations are proposed and passed, all in the name of "student-athletes", and this flimsy web of rules constantly strains to hold back what is, at its heart, a robust, irrepressible, revenue-generating machine. There ought to be a way to divert kids from this machinery who otherwise couldn't give two flips about school, and provide a better alternative than trying to fit them into that preconceived mold. (It's been touted before, but maybe a professional minor league for football and hoops would be a viable option.) The schools would move a little closer to their ideal vision of the athlete-as-student, and the NCAA could unclench their cheeks a little bit more.

So how does Notre Dame fit into this picture? Well, we don't really have to worry about the 50% rule -- ND's grad rates for football have always been among the best in the land. And along with a handful other schools -- Duke and Stanford, to name a couple -- we seem to have cracked the code on the student athlete, providing sound academic grad rates along with competitive teams. We do this in a couple of key ways: a higher academic threshold for incoming recruits, and a serious dedication to academic support once at the school.

Unlike Duke, Stanford, and the rest, however, ND is the only school actively engaged in trying to win a national championship in football, and as such, we offer an important and unique perspective for the college landscape.
We're the sole institution of higher learning that also wants (I'll stress wants) to be a real football powerhouse, on par with the Miamis and the Oklahomas of the world, while maintaining a high level of academic excellence. Due mostly to the sheer number of players involved, a football program requires much more diligence and allocation of resources to its academic well-being -- much moreso than many of the typical football schools seem to devote.

Is the whole idea of a student athlete in this most bottom-line of sports a quaint notion of a bygone era? Is it ridiculous to think that ND can compete with Oklahoma and LSU on the field and still graduate 80-plus-percent of its players? And not just in puffy Michigan-style Kinesiology programs, but in fairly rigorous curriculums, and send them off with a diploma that has some heft and value? Is it even possible?

Well, we are certainly trying. In fact, it's part of our mission. As Father Ted once put it...


“Several years ago Sports Illustrated kindly invited me to express some convictions regarding intercollegiate athletics. In a recent (1958) article entitled “Surrender at Notre Dame,” you say that I have found it impossible to live with these convictions at Notre Dame and have reversed myself, or allowed myself to be reversed, albeit reluctantly. If I read the article correctly, and separated the fact from the fiction, your conclusion is derived from the single fact of our having changed football coaches. Here are a few more facts and convictions that may suggest an alternate, although perhaps less colorful, interpretation of that single fact.

“My primary conviction has been, and is, that whatever else a university may be, it must first of all be a place dedicated to excellence. Most of my waking hours are directed to the achievement of that excellence here in the academic order. As long as we, like most American universities, are engaged in intercollegiate athletics, we will strive for excellence of performance in this area too, but never at the expense of the primary order of academic excellence.”

"He (the ND head coach) understands what we stand for and he has our confidence. Despite any syndicated surmises to the contrary, he is not expected to be Rockne, but only himself; he is not to be measured by any nostalgic calculus of wins, losses and national championships but only by the excellence of his coaching and the spirit of his teams."

“A university could make broad and significant changes in academic personnel to achieve greater excellence, and attract only a ripple of attention. But let the same university make a well-considered change in athletics for the same reason, and it sparks the ill-considered charge that it is no longer a first rate academic institution and must henceforth be considered a football factory. It seems to me a little more thought is in order regarding what makes and institution academically first rate…. What the University does athletically, assuming it to be in the proper framework, neither adds to nor subtracts anything from relevant and all-important academic facts.”

“There is no academic virtue in playing mediocre football and no academic vice in winning a game that by all odds one should lose...There has been a surrender at Notre Dame, but it is a surrender to excellence on all fronts, and in this we hope to rise above ourselves with the help of God.“

Tuesday, January 25, 2005

Trojansphere | by Jay

Apparently Heisman winner Matt Leinart had been keeping a fairly detailed and regular blog for the past year. Anyway, from an ND standpoint, it's pretty funny, in a trainwreck sort of way. Matt on movies:
I also liked 'Rudy' when I was growing up. It made me want to go to Notre Dame for a while but, of course, I grew out of it.
One of Matt's fan letters:
Matt! "Cat's are useless." Say what?!? Matt you are my favorite quarterback ever at SC and I love you dearly, but cats are not useless. You don't have to like em personally, but jeez louise! My cat is very useful. She is my little buddy and keeps me company (although she isn't a huge fan of football, too much excitement for her.) She is very amusing and does funny stuff like zooming around the house with wild look in her eye and getting pissy with the outdoor cats who get too close to the window. She is also very smart and knows many verbal cues. And a huge perk: she smells a lot better than a dog. Anyhoo, I love you just a little less today after reading of your great dislike of cats. I'm even thinking of taking down the picture of you I have above my desk. Ok, I'm messin' with ya a little bit.
But I can't rip on Matt's blog too much. Even though it's clear that someone's ghostwriting it for him, it's a pretty good "inside look". I hope he keeps it up, and I'm looking forward to what he'll write about the ND game this year. Last time around...

Notre Dame
I've always had tremendous respect for Notre Dame. I think that is the centerpiece of the rivalry--the mutual respect between two great programs. Notre Dame didn't really recruit me out of high school. I think they were featured more of a running-style quarterback at the time. By their tradition alone, they attract great players. They get top players and they have great coaches. I think Coach Willingham is an excellent coach. But, it's not just the players, the coaches, the tradition--when you think of Notre Dame, you think of all that comes with it.

The Game

I was approaching the game like any other. I was trying not to listen to the talk surrounding the game. I was trying to go in with the same attitude and I did. It just so happened we made a lot of plays and guys got open and that helps. You throw a five-yard pass to Reggie and he goes for 70. That helps. It was fun to be out there. It's easy for me to keep the discussion of awards away and just play my game.

Working On The Run
We just took what they gave us. They were trying to take away the run, so we passed. We were still able to get some key yards on the ground. Obviously, we wanted a little more, but we were able to exploit them through the air. We always want to run the ball and establish the run, but we'll keep doing the same things.

Notre Dame hardly blitzed. They had a good run defense. They played stout and physical and played back and didn't want to give up anything deep. We were able to play action them and our line blocked great for that.

Sunday, January 23, 2005

Protégé | by Jay

Tip of the hat to Hobbs over on NDN for pointing out two fine articles on Charlie from Sunday's NY Post.

"Charlie Hustle"
He was a fat, obnoxious loudmouth that didn't fit in," said Jim Washburn, a South Carolina assistant at the time and the current Tennessee Titans defensive line coach. "Everybody thought he was a [jerk] and then he became one of the most respected and loved guys down there."

"Jersey Guy Wearing Two Hats - And Both Fit Fine"

"Belichick had a significant role in getting me this [Notre Dame] job," Weis said. "They talked to Parcells a couple times, too. I'm full of gratitude toward Belichick, who helped me get the job and has made this transition period relatively easy, and also Parcells, because they called him and asked him if I was right and he recommended me for the job.

"Belichick and Parcells are the two reasons I was in position to get this job. I would not be in pro football if it wasn't for Parcells and I've grown even more since I've been here with Belichick."

Good stuff.

Friday, January 21, 2005

MEN-DO-ZAA! | by Pat

Charlie Weis continued to make his mark on the Notre Dame football program as Ruben Mendoza was hired as the new strength and conditioning coach for the Notre Dame varsity athletic teams. Mendoza comes to Notre Dame from the University of Mississippi, where he worked alongside current ND assistant coaches David Cutcliffe and John Latina, and will take over for the departed Micky Marotti.

Keeping with the "football tough" attitude that Weis is instilling in the program, Mendoza describes his approach to strength training in similar terms.

"We have a simple philosophy here at Ole Miss that combines a 'no-nonsense' approach with an 'old school' attitude," said Mendoza, who joined the Rebel athletic department in January 2001. "We have a balanced, well-rounded program. We incorporate a variety of training methods from dynamic-conjugate training to Olympic-style movements. Everything we do here is geared toward developing speed, power and strength.

"We want to instill in our student-athletes work ethic, discipline, intensity, attitude and pride. We want the student-athletes to come into the weight room in the frame of mind that they want to work hard to get better every day. Our student-athletes understand what it takes to strive for and win championships."

The 6'6", 320 lb Mendoza is no stranger to hard work himself as he graduated from Wayne State as the football team captain and a Kodak and NAIA All-American offensive lineman. After college he spent time in the NFL for the Green Bay Packers, Miami Dolphins, and Phoenix (now Arizona) Cardinals before returning to college to coordinate strength and conditioning. That sort of size and experience will come in handy should Mendoza decide to "pull an Orgeron" in the weight room.

A widely respected strength coach, Mendoza appears to always be on the lookout for ways to improve his teaching and training. While at Ole Miss he traveled to Nebraska to study their legendary weight training regimen and according to one article, "implemented a new system in Oxford where the players actually perform strength and conditioning drills in deep sand. The sand, according to reports and physical studies conducted by physicians at various research institutes, helps joints strengthen and also stabilizes the bone."

One of the perks that helped to draw Mendoza to South Bend has to be the upcoming opening of the new
Guglielmino Athletics Complex. The new football facility will be one of the best in the nation and will house the football offices, which will move from the JACC this summer. Mendoza and his staff will get to run the new 25,000 sq. ft. weight room which will include three track lanes for speed work and 40 yards of the new Prestige Turf that was recently installed on the field in the Loftus Center. No word yet on whether Mendoza will get his sand pits.

Mendoza was widely credited for increasing the strength and physicality of the Ole Miss football teams in the few years he worked with the program. Add in the fact that he has NFL O-line experience and has already worked with offensive line coach Latina at both Clemson and Ole Miss, and I think it's safe to say that the strength of our offensive and defensive lines won't be an issue. And while it doesn't seem that Mendoza is a strictly "bulk is better" type strength coach, the addition of the Gug speed training areas and returning speed coach Shawn Gaunt should help to provide the lightning to Mendoza's thunder approach.

Oh, and one more time...

MEN-DO-ZAA!!!!

This Thing of Ours | by Jay

A short, but jam-packed article about Father Jenkins today in USA Today, wherein he reiterates some of his previous comments, as well as adds a strong vote of confidence for Kevin White.

SOUTH BEND, Ind. — Notre Dame's incoming president, the Rev. John Jenkins, affirmed his support of athletics director Kevin White and defended the process that led to the controversial firing of former football coach Tyrone Willingham after three seasons.

White has been criticized by fans for the performance of the football program and the way the search for Willingham's successor turned out. The school courted Utah coach Urban Meyer, a former Notre Dame assistant, who went to Florida.

White also defended Willingham in the announcement of the firing Nov. 30.

"Kevin White has given great leadership in the past five years," Jenkins said in his campus office this week, his first formal interview on athletics. "He has been put in difficult situations. I think he performed well. I have every confidence in him."

Jenkins said he initiated phone calls to two university trustees that began the process that led to Willingham's firing. "I suppose insofar as anybody is responsible for that decision, I am," he said, "and I'll take responsibility for it."

Jenkins did not specify a level of expectation for the football program under new coach Charlie Weis. "I am not going to give an expectation in terms of won-loss (record)," Jenkins said. "I think we can and should perform at a high level on the field. I think we should, in all ways, seek to be outstanding. ... We do have a special tradition in football, and so it is a special concern that we show in all those areas — integrity, graduation rate and performance on the field — excellence."

Jenkins said Willingham's acknowledged indirect contact with the University of Washington before the season ended was not a factor. And Jenkins said the need for confidentiality was the reason he consulted a small number of administrators and two members of the board of trustees.

"Everybody feels that they should be included," Jenkins said. "It's difficult to know who to include in such a way that the circle doesn't become so wide that the appropriate level of confidentiality is lost."

Jenkins said donors who have helped fund Notre Dame's athletics budget, $39 million for the 2004-05 academic year, according to school spokesman John Heisler, did not sway the decision.

"I can say categorically that financial considerations weren't even mentioned in our discussion, at least any discussion I had with anybody," Jenkins said.

The incoming president acknowledged that while the integrity of the program had been maintained under Willingham and graduation rates were among national leaders, performance on the field had become a concern.

"Win-loss record," he said. "Obviously, your recruiting plays a role. I think programs have a momentum. If they lose that momentum, it becomes harder to recover it. ... It's the total picture of: 'What is the direction of the program? And what confidence do we have in that program?' And I guess one can infer what confidence players considering here have in that program."

Willingham declined through a spokesperson to comment.

Jenkins said he had discussed the strong response of current university president, the Rev. Edward Malloy, who registered his embarrassment. "I think we're working together well," Jenkins said.

Malloy said through a spokesman he had nothing more to add.

Let's check the scorecard. White is staying; I fired Ty, not anyone else; wins are important, as important as integrity and academics; no more decisions by committee; Monk has nothing more to say. Kind of reminds you of when Tony finally took control of the family from Uncle Jun.

Thursday, January 20, 2005

Nike camps: 40-yard dashes and shuttles | by Michael

There's no question that recruitniks love 40-yard dashes and 20-yard shuttles as a measure of a kid's worth. And to a certain extent, Rival.com's Nike camps have become the college version of the NFL combine. Everyone oohs and ahs over the recruit who shows up measuring 6'2 and 250 lbs, runs a 4.5 forty, a 4.2 shuttle and benches 185 lbs twenty-five times.

Somewhere along the way, 40-yard dashes at Nike camps acquired a kind of legitimacy. There is little question that they're generally more accurate than self-reported 40-yard dash times, and because kids at one camp are all measured under the same conditions, it's great for comparing kids at the same camp. But what happens when you try to compare kids who posted their times at separate Nike camps? Is that a good idea?

Below is some data gathered from the Rivals database for 20-yard shuttles and 40-yard dashes. All that I did was count up the number of kids who separately recorded shuttle times of 4.0 or better or 40-yard dashes of 4.4 or faster.

Shuttles
At Charlottesville, 20 kids.
At State College, 10 kids.
At Baton Rouge, 9 kids.
At Miami, 6 kids.
At Eugene, 5 kids.
At College Station, 3 kids.
At Palo Alto, 3 kids.
At San Diego, 3 kids.
At Columbus, 1 kid.
At East Rutherford, 1 kid.
At Iowa City, 1 kid.
At Atlanta, 1 kid.

40-Yard Dashes
At State College, 11 kids.
At Miami, 10 kids.
At Columbus, 5 kids.
At Charlottesville, 5 kids.
At Atlanta, 5 kids.
At East Rutherford, 3 kids.
At Baton Rouge, 2 kids.
At College Station, 2 kids.
At Palo Alto, 2 kids.
At San Diego, 2 kids.
At Iowa City, 1 kid.
At Eugene, 0 kids.

My first reaction: did someone in Charlottesville make sure the 20-yard shuttle cones were set up 20-yards apart? Maybe they were only 18 yards apart? How else can you explain the incredible disparity between the results achieved there versus other camps? Was the talent at the Charlottesville Nike camp that much better than what showed up at the other ones?

Second reaction: Is it any coincidence that the participants at State College received such high marks in both categories, compared to the other camps?

Were the athletes at State College really that much better than those at the Florida and Baton Rouge camps? Given the trends in college football and the NFL - that the majority of those players come from the states of Texas, California, Florida, Louisiana, Georgia and Ohio (with New Jersey and Pennsylvania clearly trailing those five, though I'm not sure of the exact order) these results don't seem to reflect that trend. It would seem as though the best athletes are not coming from Texas (College Station), Georgia (Atlanta) and California (San Diego/Palo Alto).

All in all, it's hard to reach any water-tight conclusions...but what it does suggest is that it's nearly impossible to adequately compare kids who ran 40-yard dashes or shuttles at different Nike camps, and that the apparent "legitimacy" that Nike camp numbers seem to command needs to be taken with a grain of salt. In other words, it's no problem to compare kids' timed events at the same camp, but that's about it as far as the usefulness of these numbers.

Wednesday, January 19, 2005

Bright Lights, Small City | by Mike

No one will ever confuse South Bend with NYC or LA. But when it comes to college football, the lights shine as brightly in South Bend as anywhere else. This is exactly what Lawrence Wilson is discovering as he mulls over his college decision.

Wilson, an athletic TE/DE, originally committed to Notre Dame under the Willingham regime, but withdrew his commitment upon Willingham's departure. Wilson's decommitment touched off a recruiting frenzy, as Ohio State, Florida, and Michigan leapt at the opportunity to secure his pledge.

However, it is the recruiting efforts of Charlie Weis and his staff that have thrust Wilson's name into the national spotlight. Because he was being recruited by Weis, Wilson has already been mentioned on Monday Night Football. Not many high school prospects can make that claim.

Recently, Wilson received a recruiting visit from seven (!) Notre Dame assistant coaches. While many college coaches employ innovative tactics in their attempts to secure commitments, it's no coincidence that such efforts become national stories when Notre Dame is involved. To wit, the latest from ESPN.com:
SOUTH BEND, Ind. -- Notre Dame wants to make sure that a high school defensive end from Ohio knows he's wanted in South Bend.

Seven coaches showed up at Lawrence Wilson's home in Akron, Ohio, on Sunday. That's the maximum number of coaches allowed on the road recruiting at one time.
Do you think this would have been a story on ESPN for any other school? Apparently this isn't an unknown recruiting tactic, yet for some reason, when it happens with ND, it merits a headline.

Yep, the lights are a little hotter in South Bend. Hope Wilson has his shades.

When News Breaks... | by Teds

Another Beloved ND Relic Collapses Before Everyone's Eyes

The remainder of the Gateway complex collapsed onto the roof of CJ's PubSouth Bend, IN - They say that sometimes you eat the bar, and sometimes the bar eats you. And sometimes, the bar just gets eaten by a six-story apartment building instead.

The old Gateway apartment complex has been under demolition for about a week, but Wednesday afternoon the remainder of the six-story building collapsed on CJ’s Pub on North Michigan Street.

Crews from Warner and Sons of Osceola had been tearing down the complex, now owned by Memorial Health System, when the unexpected collapse occurred.

A cook, a waitress and a bartender were inside the pub when the Gateway building collapsed. They escaped unhurt, although barkeep Kell Varnsen was understandably shaken up by the incident.

"It's enough to make one wax nostalgic for the days when the University and local authorities conspired to thwart student-loved hangouts by simply taking their licenses away and shutting them down," Varnsen sighed.

"Dropping entire buildings on them just seems, well, a little too 'on the nose' for my tastes."

Rick Medick, the owner of CJ’s Pub, says, “I was just walking into the building, so I missed the whole collapse by about 10 seconds. It sounded like a bomb going off. Truth be told, I haven't heard a racket like that since ND's old Director of Football Operations got stiffed on Secretary's Day."

The wrecking crew is working to stabilize the rubble and pull debris off of CJ’s Pub. Utility crews have also been working on the situation.

Crew foreman Art Vandelay brushed off the magnitude of the job ahead.

"We just finished up a long-term project over at the Notre Dame football offices. Digging out from under six stories worth of heavy brick and construction debris is gonna be a breeze compared to that."

Unfortunately, Medick says there is serious structural damage to the pub.

Memorial Health System owns the building and property. The hospital issued a statement saying they are thankful no one was injured in the collapse. “We will be working closely with our contractor and their insurance company to investigate the cause and identify next steps to restore the damaged pub and proceed with the removal of debris. Don't worry -- Ricky Joe should be back singing the Rodeo Song before you know it."

"In the meantime, Legends is just a hop, skip and a jump away from CJ's, and we hear from reputable sources that it's 'where legends are made'. Not to mention chicken wings, and $2.00 margaritas on 'Fiesta Thursdays'. Seriously, though, check it out."

The hospital has plans to turn the property into a parking lot. Rumor has it that the lot is poised to become the University's new Green Field for home football games. "Sure, it's a little far from campus, " said Bill Kirk, Notre Dame's VP for Residence Life, "but tailgating deserves its own special place on gameday. Preferably in another county, but this is a good first step."

Tuesday, January 18, 2005

Coach Cut | by Jay

Nice write-up on Coach Cutcliffe from the South Bend Trib yesterday. Brady's obviously his starting QB going into spring practice, but Cutcliffe has some choice words that should stoke the competitive fires a bit:

"(Quinn) is in a new system with new coaches," Cutcliffe said. "He's got to reprove himself ... the competition is there. What we can do with the young players at quarterback, how far we can bring them, I don't know.

"But I want them to compete to be starters and if they don't then they are not the right kind of people to be quarterbacks in our system.

"Brady is the starter. There is no secret behind that because he has the experience and he has the time," he continued. "But he is also in a position where he is having to reprove himself so he's starting all over again. I think if he uses that to his advantage, he will gain great ground."

Check out the whole article here.

Monday, January 17, 2005

81 | by Jay

It’s those kick returns. The football equivalent of a one-punch knockout, except that it is more deliciously anticipated, or at least awaited, yet always a surprise when it happens.

The ball floats skyward while down below nearly two dozen bodies perform a confused choreography. Sometimes the bodies fan out – either to pursue No. 81 or, depending on their alliances, to throw a miserable two-second block – two seconds? – on his behalf. Sometimes they converge at midfield, a dangerous clot of tacklers zeroing in on this poor man with the ball. Once in a while it’s an awful collision, the kick catcher looking up from the ball just in time to collect 230 hurtling pounds in his face mask. Usually in this game, the play ends with a whimper, the victim slowed by the gauntlet and eventually buried harmlessly in a pile.

But sometimes, more often with Tim Brown than anybody in the country, this muddle down below becomes suddenly transformed. This particle emerges from the mid-field jumble with an astonishing suddenness. The acceleration is breathtaking. “Like a draft when he goes by you,” Michigan State coach George Perles remarked.

No two of these are ever alike. Last week, against Air Force, Brown simply smashed up the middle to open field, or mostly open field. The punter remained lamely holding the fort. Punters are the worst.

“It can be kind of pitiful,” Brown agrees. “But I don’t think they open their eyes anyway.”

Or perhaps, as against Michigan State, it’s entirely freelance. One of those was supposed to be a fair catch and there was no return blocking scheme set up. But he caught the ball – not even Brown knows why – and curled toward a sideline. That acceleration again. He whooshed past everybody, his 4.3-second time in the 40 stirring up a breeze by his own bench.

“Sometimes I break tackles, sometimes I run by people,” he says, trying to be helpful. Explanations, though, are exasperating. “I find it hard to explain. I really don’t know what’s going on, except I’m trying not to get hit.”

It is one of football’s greatest sights, Tim Brown not getting hit. Picture it.

-- Richard Hoffer, LA Times


What picture sticks in your mind when you think of Tim Brown, Irish football hero, Heisman Trophy winner, and surefire lock for the NFL Hall of Fame?

He was of average build for a receiver, about six feet, one-ninety, and he wore oversized shoulder pads fit for a lineman. He caught passes, mostly over the middle, and somehow, with a juke and a cut he’d make you miss, and turn a ten-yard toss-and-catch into a seventy yard romp into the endzone. He got open – a lot. And he caught everything.

He was fast, but he wasn’t a sprinter. He had shifty moves; his hips seemed to go one way while his body went the other. His remarkable peripheral vision enabled him to see the entirety of the field, his eyes anticipating danger, and he’d adjust and change course in a split second.

He was a triple threat, taking handoffs, catching passes, and fielding kicks and punts. He pioneered the importance of “all-purpose yards”, and single-handedly made the stat famous.

And even when he didn’t touch the ball, he changed the dynamic of the game, drawing double (and triple) teams to open up other options, inducing short punts and squib kicks, throwing blocks downfield to help out his teammates.

Off the field, he was contemplative and analytical, with a strong faith and a real dedication to the guys in the locker room. Incredible work ethic. Great sense of humor.

The superlatives that resonate: hardworking, humble, smart, versatile. One of the all-time greats, and for many Irish fans, their absolute favorite player, ever. He had a combination of intense competitiveness and sincere modesty that’s so rare these days, and it’s no exagerration to say that Tim was good at everything he did, on and off the field. As Lou Holtz once said, “He’s special. He’s the type of guy, you’re around him just a few minutes and you can tell: he isn’t average. He’s isn’t an average athlete, and he isn’t an average person.”

And now, amazingly, it looks like we’re getting the legend back. The rumor’s been floating for about a week or so, but on Saturday Tim confirmed that he was in talks to return to Notre Dame in some capacity, probably as a co-recruiting coordinator or a player liaison. He may moonlight as a NFL receiver for another season or two, but come next year, he’ll be working for his alma mater once again.

And so, in light of this excellent news, we thought we’d take the opportunity to pay a little tribute to one of our favorites, No. 81.

--------

“You know how moms are.” -- Tim Brown.

When Tim was a kid growing up in Dallas, Texas, he knew he was talented. “I just realized there were certain things I could do that other kids just couldn’t seem to do. I don’t know why that is,” he remarked later. Maybe it’s because I’m special.”

He grew up in a very religious family, and his mother, Josephine Brown, had a career path worked out for young Tim: go to college, become a Pentecostal minister.

(Even at the Heisman ceremony, right there in the Downtown Athletic Club, as the award was being presented, Mrs. Brown pushed the idea. “I love my son. I’m proud of him. But one day, he will give up football and become a minister. I really believe that,” she said to the reporters. For the record, Brown doesn’t reject the idea, but he seems to relegate it to later in life. “When the time comes, I will make that decision. But right now, I’ve got to do what’s in front of me.”)

Josephine objected to competitive sports, so she forbade her 5’4” son from playing freshman football in high school. Tim joined the band instead, but after a year he dropped the bass drum in favor of a helmet and shoulder pads, getting his father Eugene to sign the permission slip, unbeknownst to his mother.

“He kind of slipped football on me. Until the band leader called wanting to know why he was skipping practice, I was still thinking he was in the band,” Josephine said.

“The old band story,” said Tim. It worked.

Woodrow Wilson High had only 25 players on their varsity squad, and they were terrible, winning a grand total of four games in Tim’s career. Still, Brown was a standout. “I played wide receiver and running back, returned kickoffs and punts and also played quarterback and free safety. And I played them pretty well. I think that was a big eye-catcher for the recruiters.” He scored 25 touchdowns in his variety of roles, but the team never enjoyed success.

“Possibly it’s because when a bunch of guys think more about getting drunk than playing football, that’s what happens. They just had other aspirations, things they concentrated on, and football wasn’t one of them,” he remarked.

Funnily enough, Brown was also the sports editor of the school paper (and was elected VP of his senior class), and he often found he had to write feature stories about himself. Too modest to print a byline, he wrote them anonymously. “I always ended up writing about myself, but I tried to act like someone else wrote it when I wrote about games I played in. I wouldn’t put my byline on the story. But everyone knew who the sports editor was.”

He had a pretty good senior year on the football field, but in a theme that would repeat itself throughout his career, he was lightly regarded, and was not named to the Texas All-State HS team. Recruiting interest started to trickle in, with Iowa, Oklahoma, Nebraska among others doing some preliminary inquiry. But the decision came down to SMU and Notre Dame. Josephine Brown lobbied hard for SMU so that Tim would be close to home. In fact, Tim was close to signing with SMU when the recruiting scandals broke out, and SMU was placed on probation.

“I really thought I was going to end up at SMU. I’m definitely glad I didn’t end up going there. In the end, I figured if football didn’t work out and I had to have something to fall back on, a Notre Dame education was best," Tim said.

ND was overjoyed. Assistant coach Jay Robertson, who had recruited him, was effusive in his praise: “He was phenomenal – like smoke through a keyhole. He had the sixth sense of anticipating where trouble was. And he had the quickness and athletic ability to get away from it."

(By the way, is "like smoke through a keyhole" one of the most evocative descriptions you'll ever hear about a football player? I'm still not sure what it means, but it seems so damn cool.)

---------

“He’s a thrill to throw to. I can toss a five-yard pass and I never know what’s going to happen.” -- Terry Andrysiak

The image “http://images.nfl.com/photos/img7956658.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.Brown arrived on Campus in the fall of '84 and promptly ingratiated himself to his teammates. "They called me Country Boy...they thought Texas was a hick state."

Tim saw the field as a freshman, playing third-string wide receiver and returning a few kicks. He got off to an ignoble start -- in his first game, he fumbled a kickoff and Purdue recovered.

The Boilermakers got 3 cheap points off the turnover, and ended up winning 23-21. Brown wasn't fazed. “I knew what I could do. It was just a matter of bouncing back.” Brown finished 1984 tied with Milt Jackson as the #2 receiver on the team.

The next year he started to make a few waves. Against Michigan State, he would return the first of many kickoffs in his career, a 93-yard beauty. It was the first Irish kickoff return for a TD in three years. Later in the game, he caught a 49-yard pass that set up another Irish touchdown.

Still, the Irish were laboring under the inept leadership of Gerry Faust, and were getting booed at home routinely. The offense was mostly a predictable and boring reliance on Allen Pinkett, a great talent, but over-utilized (immortalized in the slogan known to many Irish fans of that era: "Pinkett, Pinkett, Pass, Punt").

For Brown, the two years under Faust were “really tough. It’s nothing against him. He’s a great man and he did all he could. I just felt he was really in over his head.” Faust was fired and replaced by Lou Holtz after the season ended, and for Brown, this would prove to be quite fortuitous.

---------

“Who’s 81? He’s good." -- Beth Holtz.

The image “http://www.irishlegends.com/irish/products/loutim.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.When Lou Holtz arrived, everything changed for Brown. And for Holtz, discovering No. 81 on the roster was like finding a diamond in a coal mine. Holtz quickly decided that Brown was being underused, and found there were plenty of ways to get him involved in the offense. In addition to keeping him on the return teams, he bumped him up to first-string receiver, and even put him in at tailback in some wishbone formations.

“After three days of spring practice, I made the comment that Tim Brown may be the best football player I’ve ever seen," Holtz said. "He just grasped things. He has an awareness on the field of what he needs to do. He knows the down and distance and when to try to outrun someone and when to cut it back. It’s nothing you can teach or coach.”

This would be the dawning of the classic hybrid role that Holtz would install time and again, first with Tim Brown, and later with the Rocket.

It was the annual game against USC that really launched Brown's reputation as a premiere college football player. On that Thanksgiving weekend at the Coliseum, Tim had a 57-yard kickoff return, a 49-yard catch, and a 56-yard punt return. Brown had 13 touches and 252 all-purpose yards.

He finished out 1986 with 45 catches, 846 receiving yards, and 254 yards rushing on 59 carries, and 698 kickoff return yards, for a total of 1,937 all-purpose yards. He scored 9 touchdowns: 5 receiving, 2 rushing, and 2 on kickoff returns.

Brown had mixed feelings about running the ball out of the backfield. “I like running the ball because you have a chance to see where everybody’s going. But at this level, I don’t think I could take the punishment. "

Holtz agreed. “He’ll run physically, but if he does it on a continuous basis, he will not be the same player he is.”

-----------

The image “http://www.irishlegends.com/irish/products/images/brown.JPG” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.“What a move Timmy put on him. I don’t know where a dance is being held tonight, but that’s the only place you might see another move like that.” -- Lou Holtz.

1987 was the pinnacle of Brown's collegiate career, and the game against Michigan State was his finest moment. He returned not one, but two punts against the Spartans.

The first return was 71 yards, a beautiful tackle-breaking jaunt helped along by two key blocks. At one point Spartan cover man Todd Krumm taunted Brown as he ran up the field. "He was saying, Come on, come on," Brown related later. "So I came to him." One swivel-hip fake later, and Krumm was left in the dust.

The second return was shorter (66 yards) but much more impressive. ND put on a 10-man rush, and Brown had no blockers. In fact, “I was supposed to call for a fair catch” Brown said later.

“But we knew Greg Montgomery [MSU punter] had a 53-yard average. We figured he’d overkick the coverage, and that’s exactly what he did.”

Brown said he was going to run the return out of bounds for a short gain until he sensed the Spartans were overflying their mark. In a flash, he burst past all seven. He beat three others then raced toward Montgomery, the last defender.

“One and then another ran past me,” Brown said. “Then another one left his lane, and pretty soon it was just me and the punter.”

“I had to beat the punter. If I got tackled by the punter, I knew I’d hear it from my teammates.”

With a fake and a dodge, he put a beautiful move on Montgomery that buckled his knees and sunk him to the dirt.

Brown also caught 4 passes for 72 yards in the game. All told, he touched the ball 14 times for 275 all-purpose yards, and cemented his reputation as a legitimate Heisman candidate.

Brown was typically modest. “I think this game might have helped me out a little, but I think our defense deserves it more. They gave us field position.”

A few games later, Brown got to showcase how well he played without the ball. Against USC, he was held to only 109 all-purpose yards. Trojan coach Larry Smith had ordered squib kicks and high, short punts. Said Smith, “I’ll give them 10 yards on a kick with no return. I’m no dummy.”

Instead of carrying the offense, Brown threw several key blocks that paved the way for Irish scores.

He also had a long catch called back when an overzealouos referee called the play dead a little too early.

“The official told me it was an inadvertent whistle," Holtz said. "I couldn’t blame him. It’s natural from somebody who hasn’t seen much of Timmy Brown to think, on a play like that, ‘There ain’t no way that sucker can get out of this one.’”

-------------

“It’s nice to pick up a magazine and see my name mentioned with the Heisman, but star-gazing can hurt you. My feeling is if it happens, it happens.” -- Tim Brown

The image “http://i.timeinc.net/subs2/images/si/sistore/products/1987/0831_mid.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.As 1987 wound down, No. 81 found himself the subject of deserving, but intense Heisman hype. Yet, none of it came from Notre Dame, or Brown himself.

The low-key response was vintage Brown. “No, I’m not worried about it. I’m only concerned that we keep on winning and that I go out and play good. They were talking about me winning the Heisman, but I think those guys (the defense) deserve it.”

Holtz, perhaps in a bit of creative oratory, seemed to downplay it while bringing it up. “We don’t plan on doing anything special for Tim Brown and the Heisman award.”

Still, the hype was there, and as often happens when you get too much of a good thing, national sentiment turned against him late in the season. Brown heard a lot of reasons why he wasn’t worthy. There was focus on a couple of dropped passes, some terrible losses against Miami and Penn State. As the year went on, teams started to short kick him, kick it away or squib it, and his all-purpose yardage totals started to diminish.

“Air Force kicks two out of bounds and three more so high I had to call for fair catches. The one I returned, I kind of thought he was trying to kick it out of bounds, too," observed Brown. He had 25 return opportunities in ’86; only about half that in 87.

Furthermore, there was a sentiment that the whole idea of "all-purpose yards" was somehow illegitimate.

As one letter to the editor put it, “How long will the nation’s sportswriters let themselves be duped by the inflated 'total yards' statistic pumped out by the ND publicity department on the behalf of Tim Brown? Total Yards includes kickoff return yards which, for each kickoff, contains about 20 yards of running through empty space before meeting any tacklers. I am a 38-year-old executive and even I could lumber for 15 yards per kickoff return."

Pitt fullback Ironhead Hayward, a Heisman candidate himself, jumped into the fray. “I thought the Heisman was supposed to be somebody who dominated his position, not somebody who runs all over the field playing hide and seek.”

Mike Downey of the LA Times wrote, “If TB played for any other school, there is no way he would have a shot at the Heisman. His statistics just didn’t measure up." And yet, in the end, Downey argued that there was nobody more valuable to his team than Brown. “So there is nothing wrong with awarding the Heisman to someone who was extremely valuable to his team, as Tim Brown has been, rather than someone who just piled up better statistics.”

Brown essentially concurred. “I’m not going to apologize for going to ND. I went there because I felt I could better myself as a person, and I found out it helped me in football also.”

--------------

"He’s incredibly valuable -- even when he doesn’t get the ball.” -- ND Heisman winner Leon Hart

The image “http://www.herff-jones.com/corpaward/images/heisman.JPG” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.In the history of the Heisman, runners and passers dominate. Even in the heyday of the two-way athlete, almost every winner was primarily a running back or a quarterback. And so it was something of an anomaly that Brown would win. He was only the 3rd receiver to take the award, the others being Johnny Rogers in 1972 and ND's own Leon Hart in 1949. Brown finished way ahead of the second place honoree, Don McPherson of Syracuse (the perennial trivia answer Gordie Lockbaum of Holy Cross finished third).

Although they were both receivers, Hart and Brown couldn’t have been more different. Hart was 6’5 and weighed 252 pounds, which was gargantuan for his era. He was a “giant end” who played both offense and defense.

Yet Hart admired Brown. “The important thing with Tim Brown is, he affects the game so subtly that anybody with a trained eye can see what’s occurring when the other team doesn’t kick to him and they loft the ball on a punt so that the teammates can get down under it. They only kick a 25-yard punt instead of a 40-yard punt, and Tim gained 15 yards just by standing there. So he signals for a fair catch and actually gains yards.”

“But the important thing is what Holtz does with him," Hart explained. "His talent is such that they double- and triple-cover him, they put him out wide to the right and then run the option opposite Brown, and the defense doesn’t have enough men left over the cover what ends up as the QB and the pitch man."

Brown responded to the award in his typical modesty, and shared the award with his team. “I thank God, and my coaches and teammates. I said from the start, this was a team award. It would not have been possible if they did not block for me or pass the ball to me. God bless you all, and thank you very much.”

Although the Heisman award is still populated by mostly QBs and RBs, Brown did pave the way for the consideration of other positions for the award, and both Desmond Howard and Charles Woodson owe a lot to his legacy.

(Random Heisman fact: an ND player has finished among the top 10 in Heisman ballotting 35 times in the 68-year history of the award.)

--------------

"I got my towel back. That was that.” -- Tim Brown

Perhaps the low point of Brown's career -- and it wasn't even that low, despite the negative publicity that surrounded the incident -- happened during the Cotton Bowl against Texas A&M in 1987.

In the 4th quarter, Brown was tackled on a kickoff return. After the whistle sounded, he chased an A&M player and tackled him from behind because he had stolen his towel.

It was a blue towel with gold trim and a “T 81” embroidered on it. A gift from teammate Cedric Figaro.

The towel thief was Warren Barhorst, a non-scholarship player who is the infamous “Twelfth Man” on A&M’s kickoff coverage team – a longtime tradition in A&M lore, where a student walk-on plays on the kickoff coverage team.

The score was already 28-10 when Brown was tackled and Barhorst landed on top of him.

Brown got up and ran about 20 yards towards the Aggie bench to catch up with Barhorst. Brown jumped on his back and fell with him to the ground. Benches cleared and surrounded the scuffle.

“Evidently, they had something planned on the sidelines. One guy held me down, and another guy took my towel. I didn’t mean to tackle him. It looked like I tackled him, I know. But I got my towel back. That was that.”

Brown did his part in the game. Returned the opening kickoff 37 yards, caught 10 passes, including a TD, and finished with 238 all-purpose yards. But ND got crushed, 35-10.

Incidentally, Barhorst had been in on only 5 kickoffs all season, and when he landed on top of Brown, it was his first (and last) college tackle. “What a way to end my football career,” Barhorst exclaimed jubilantly.

Brown is a first-ballot NFL hall-of-famer. Wonder what Warren Barhorst is up to these days.

--------------

“I’ve never seen anybody in this football game like Timmy Brown. His mere presence…his leadership...his blocking...the things he does without the ball.” -- Lou Holtz

Brown left ND as the all-time receiving leader with 2,493 yards. He accounted for 5,025 all-purpose yards, scored 22 touchdowns, and averaged 116.8 yards per game over his entire career.

Yet in a continuation of what seems a lifetime of underappreciation, many pro scouts were poo-pooing his accomplishments. Some were trumpeting Michael Irvin, Anthony Miller, or Sterling Sharpe as better pro prospects. Said Tampa Bay coach Ray Perkins of Sharpe, "He's more of a football player [than Brown]."

Brown ended up going 6th overall, to the Los Angeles Raiders. Aundray Bruce, Neil Smith, Bennie Blades, Paul Gruber, and Rickey Dixon were all picked ahead of him. Sterling Sharpe went one spot later, and Michael Irvin went 11th.

------------

The image “http://sportsmed.starwave.com/i/magazine/new/tim_brown_b.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.Brown and the Raiders couldn't agree on a contract right away, but Brown, in an act that seems completely foreign to NFL fans these days, still reported to camp anyway. He signed a temporary 1-year deal at half the going rate just to get in camp and get started (later he agreed to a 4-year, $2.8 million deal.)

In his first regular-season game with the Raiders, he returned a kickoff 97 yards for a TD. By the end of the year, he had broken Gayle Sayers’s league record for total yardage by a rookie with 2317 yards. He racked up 725 receiving yards, 50 rushing, 1,098 on KO returns and 444 on punt returns.

He was named to the Pro Bowl as a rookie kick returner, and also won the Rookie of the Year.

Jim Murray, the great sportswriter of the LA Times, looked back on the low expectations for Brown following his selection by the Raiders:

“So, the Raiders sighed and took what they could get. In this case, it was Timothy Donell Brown, of the Dallas, Texas, Browns, a nice enough young man, soft-spoke, dependable. He’d gone to Notre Dame, which was good, but he was a kind of what-is-it quantity on the football field, which wasn’t.

Then, too, he had won the Heisman Trophy. Now for those of you who think this would be a big plus, you haven’t been paying close attention. Heisman winners have historically been something less than sensational in the pros…besides, there was a notion that for a Notre Damer to win it, all he had to do was be able to frost a glass and not fumble too much.

It’s hard to believe the Raiders didn’t have high hopes for this terrific Tim. But kickoff specialists are a dime a dozen in the NFL. Even Brown’s Heisman didn’t stand out: there were three of them already on the team.

It’s hard to think of a Heisman-Notre Dame luminary, the most celebrated college player of his season as a surprise in his pro debut. But Tim Brown has made a lot of NFL owners look frowningly at their general managers.

Who would have thought you’d get a star like this out of a Heisman? Here’s a guy who started at the top and went up, who rose above the adversity of reputation. Before him, all-purpose used to signify a guy who did a lot of things – with mediocrity. Tim Brown does so many things so well, the Raiders should just be glad he never took up baseball."

In the first game of 1989, he blew out his knee and missed the rest of the season.

------------

“I hate that I have to ask to play football, but if it comes down to that, I’m going to do whatever it takes to get me on the field.” -- Tim Brown

Recovering from the injury took a lot longer than Brown anticipated, even after it was completely healed. He found that when he returned the team, he wasn't nearly as involved in the offense, and he soon was begging for playing time.

To be sure, he wasn't a "me-first" player by any stretch, not Keyshawn saying "give me the damn ball." Rather, he felt like he could contribute, and he didn't think he was doing enough.

“Every time you lose, you can’t help but ask yourself, ‘Is there anything more I could have done?’ Then, it starts to become an ego thing.”

Later, he explained how he went to talk things over with Al Davis. He described what the eccentric Raider owner said to him, mimicking his drawl: “Ya doing aw great job, Timmer, just keep it up. We love ya.”

But Al loved breakaway speed, long bombs and track stars. Willie Gault – fast as lightning, running the streak pattern -- was his prototype, not a dependable but boring over-the-middle possession guy like Brown. Brown was frustrated and contemplated leaving.

He thought a clause in his contract would make him a free agent after the season, but the commissioner ruled in the Raiders favor, and he was stuck with the team for another two years.

But rather than slinking into training camp and pouting his way through the season, Brown took the opposite approach. “I prepared myself harder than I ever have in the off-season. And I worked harder than I ever did in training camp. I wasn’t going to get the money, but I still play this game because I love it.”

He gradually worked his way back into the offensive scheme, and established a great chemistry with new Raiders QB Jeff Hostetler.

Jim Murray again, looking back on this period:

“The Raiders didn’t quite know what to do with Tim. He was a wide receiver but he also returned punts and kickoffs. Stumped, they put him on special teams.

Al Davis’s quarterbacks were known as mad bombers, blitzkriegers. His teams didn’t need the ball much. Let the other guys push it up through the mud. Davis’s teams struck like cavalry.

They had some trouble seeing Tim Brown in this scheme. Tim is not going to anchor the Olympic relay team. They liked his moves – on kickoffs and punts. They were less sold on fly patterns. One year, in 1991, he started only one game.

But gradually, one thing began to dawn on this Raider brain trust: When he was in there – usually on third and long – Brown would be as wide open as Dodge City on a Saturday night.

Brown perfected his craft. He studied defenders the way a pitcher studies hitters, but mostly he studied coverages. He found the soft spots, the open spaces in his opponents’ zones. He exploited them.

And now, Tim Brown is striking a blow for Heisman winners everywhere."

The image “http://images.nfl.com/photos/img6932375.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.In ’94 he had his best season to date. He caught 89 balls for 1,309 receiving yards and made the Pro Bowl for the first time as a receiver, not just a special teams player.

And from there, he was simply one of the best players in the league for over a decade, and one of the best players in the history of the game.

Brown went on to capture almost all of the Raider franchise records: most pro bowls, most touchdowns, most receiving yards, most receptions, most yards from scrimmage, most punt returns, most 1,000 yard seasons (9).
  • Led the Raiders 11 times in receiving yards.
  • Was the only raider to score on a run, a reception, a punt return and a kickoff return.
  • Went to 9 pro bowls.
His overall NFL standing is among the top two or three at his position. He's had the most consecutive 50+ catch seasons in NFL history (11).

He's 2nd all time receiving yards in the NFL, after Jerry Rice.

He's 3rd in receptions all-time – and he could move up to second with 7 more catches.

And he's tied for 3rd in receiving touchdowns (100).

-----------

Last year, Brown was let go by the Raiders, and he elected to sign a one-year contract with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers rather than retire. At the press conference to announce he would no longer be a Raider, Brown was his usual honest, gracious self.

“This is a very emotional day for me. I gave my heart and soul to the organization. I battled as much as I possibly could on the field, and tried to restore the image off the field. Obviously coming in here, me being a Notre Dame guy, everybody said that I didn’t fit in here as the typical Raider. I have thoroughly enjoyed my career here. Mr. D and I have not always seen eye to eye, but we have always had respect for each other.”

For his part, Al Davis praised Brown. “One of the truly great players who has ever played the game, and obviously one of the truly great players that has ever played for the Raiders.”

-----------

“One thing I have never done is take the game for granted. I have always known that any given play could be your last.” -- Tim Brown

On Saturday, the Tampa Bay Tribune reported that Tim Brown will be joining Charlie Weis's staff in some capacity this year, although exactly what his role will be is dependent on if he chooses to play another year in the NFL at the same time.

"I will have some title there,'' Brown said of Notre Dame. ''And whatever the title is, it won't interfere with me playing ball - whether I play ball or do TV or whatever.''

Brown met Thursday with Notre Dame athletic director Kevin White to discuss aiding the Irish in their attempted return to prominence.

Brown's role likely will be decided during a future meeting with new coach Charlie Weis.

''Charlie's not in the loop right now,'' Brown said, referring to Weis' role as offensive coordinator of the New England Patriots. ''Once he's out of the playoffs, after the Super Bowl, we'll be able to come up with an official title and see if I can help with recruiting or be a player liaison or something so players there can have an outlet.''

Brown said it might be another month or two before he decides whether to retire as a player.

''I don't know if I'll make a decision before March or not,'' he said.

Brown said he intends to devote a lot of time to the Irish program if he decides to retire as a player.

'If I'm not playing I can have a lot more of an impact,'' he said. ''If I do decide to play ball, then it's up to what Charlie wants me to do. After the playoffs we'll have a chance to iron some things out.''


Whatever the exact timeline happens to be, it seems certain that Tim will be returning to ND, and fairly soon. Even if he plays another year in the NFL, it looks like he's pretty close to retiring, and when he does, we can expect his role and responsibility for the Irish to be substantial.

For a while in the mid-90s, I worked in El Segundo, California, where the Raiders had their practice facility, and I used to see Tim out at lunch a couple of times a year. Always had a smile for me when I mentioned the ND connection; always was gracious in talking to anyone who recognized him and said hello.

Like most fans, I remember Tim Brown for his great catches and his electrifying kick returns. I remember the games and the touchdowns, the Heisman award and the towel incident. I remember liking the Raiders just a little bit more when they drafted Tim, and I remember feeling some gratification that Brown was one of the few Heisman winners to actually live up to his billing.

But I'm glad I had the opportunity to take a look back over his career, and dig up some stories that maybe I'd missed or I'd forgotten. The complete picture of Tim Brown, the person, is one of not just God-given talent, but incredible honesty, integrity, and perseverance.

I can't imagine a better homecoming and sense of personal satisfaction for Tim in this next stage of his professional life, nor can I imagine a greater benefit for the University than having No. 81 back on campus. Congratulations, Tim: another brilliant run is about to begin.

Sunday, January 16, 2005

Pointless | by Dylan

As we head into the long dark of the post-bowl, pre-Big 12 vs. Division III portion of the college football year, I think it’s high time we diverted from the oblong and talked a little roundball. Hence, BGS’s first basketball post.

The image “http://www.nba.com/media/suns/thomas_notredame_200.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.I have to say that, despite the gaudy 11-3 record, I am not terribly high on the Irish right now. At the end of last year, I was terrifically optimistic about the returning team, particularly with the addition of Latimore. I had visions of a top 10 squad and a return to the Sweet 16. But when I look at the schedule and the dearth of RPI-bouncing wins, I see a ten-loss Irish squad (potentially 9-7 in the BE) once again bubbling down the stretch to an eventual date with East Tennessee State or somesuch in the NIT.

Defensively, there are few places to find fault, so I won’t. But this team is an offensive enigma. When you take the parts individually, you see a team that should cruise into the mid-70s in every game, but they’ve scored more than 73 points only five times, and two of those games were the exhibitions against St. Joe and Quincy. Their output in their three (!) road games has been 60 (Michigan), 55 (Indiana), and 66 (SHU). So what gives?

My incredibly technical analysis of the situation is this: they are too guardable. Even Chris Thomas, who was an absolute ankle-breaker two years ago, seems to be unable to shake a defender. I’m trying to figure out how this could still be the case, since it was also true last year, and I can only think of two possible reasons. One, that Brey is unable to implement an offense that makes the most of the players’ abilities, or two, that the players are collectively unable to execute Brey’s offense. I tend to think it’s the latter. For the sake of brevity, I’ll settle on one primary culprit, and that’s the high pick-and-roll.

This is the second consecutive year of watching us butcher this most fundamental of offensive plays. It would be easy to blame the lack of effectiveness on Torin Francis, whose footwork seems to have been taught by a tag team of Tim Kempton and a Class Two Power Loader and whose hands make the Seattle Seahawks’ look like the Indianapolis Colts’. It would also be fair to question why Brey insists on using Francis when it’s clear that, were Francis ever to get the ball on the “roll” portion of the play, he does not have the “face-up” moves or the explosion to the bucket needed to finish the play. However, I think the problem really lies at the point. Thomas, who is generally running the point more effectively, doesn’t set up the semi-mobile Francis properly, and doesn’t force his own man into the screen. This generally results in one of two bad outcomes, either Thomas’ defender slides over the screen and Francis’ man does not have to fully commit to the switch, or Francis’ man simply abandons him and joins in a double team out of which Thomas refuses to pass. In either case the high pick works to the advantage of the defense, which is the definition of a poor offensive play.

This leads to phase two of the problem with the Thomas-Francis pick-and-roll combo. As Thomas tries to dribble out of a double team thirty feet from the basket, the offense just...slows.....down. What happens next is a hasty reset, some listless perimeter passing, and then a three. Luckily for the Irish, those threes have been falling pretty consistently (with the exception of the 9-30 effort against Syracuse). ND plays best when they shoot 15 to 20 threes a game. Chuck more than that, and they throw themselves at the mercy of the defense and the iron. That’s what happened against Syracuse. Threes became a substitute for offense. Thirty of fifty-two field goal attempts were threes. Against St. John’s, the number was thirty-four of sixty-five. That is simply not going to work on the road in the Big East, where they play seven of their remaining twelve conference games.

Mike Brey is the coach. He’s quite good. But I know he’s waiting to hear what I have to say, so here’s my three point plan:

“Alfordize” Colin Falls – Break out some tape of the 1986-87 Hoosiers. Run Falls through the lane, around baseline screens, curls, whatever. He’s a spectacular shooter, but his current M.O. of floating outside the three point line does not put enough stress on the defense. ND needs to make Falls a team-wide defensive priority for the other guys. Force their bigs to account for him on switches. Set up mismatches. Get them confused.

Let Francis Become His Inner Dale Davis – This is not meant as an insult. Dale Davis was a great NBA player. But he was never the first offensive option on any of his teams. He and Francis share the same plodding, two-footed jumping technique, the same stony hands, the same trouble initiating the break, and the same warrior’s heart. Francis (and Brey) needs to focus his game on his rebounding and shot-blocking abilities. He plays like he’s 6’8” at one end and 7’0” at the other. Let Latimore roam the offensive low post. Torin should be weak-side support.

Expand The Rotation and Solidify The Roles– I know, I know. Hit me with the Jere Macura jokes. But we need to have a Torrian Jones-type back on the floor. We need to have some semblance of an athletic “3” to get things moving, both in transition and in the half court sets. Quinn/Thomas, Quinn/Falls, and Falls/Cornette are near-redundant combinations. Carter and Cornett need to see more time. Cornette, though a nice shooter, needs to play more like a “3.5” than a “2.5.”

Are these tweaks even possible? You have to assume that Brey has tried, but the materials and the chemistry just aren’t there. I fear the best the Irish have to hope for this year is a return to the Wrong Final Four.

Saturday, January 15, 2005

Hord joins the Irish | by Pat

Notre Dame picked up its 12th* verbal commitment when Kansas City Rockhurst wide receiver DJ Hord picked a Notre Dame hat out of a duffel bag on NBC during the halftime of the US Army High-School All-American game. And while I wanted to write something positive about the talented Hord and the recruiting class that Charlie Weis is building, I have to talk about the sheer comedy value of the Game that Lemming BuiltTM. That is, after I shower to get rid of the creepy feeling I got from watching the broadcast.

Yeah, I admit to watching it. I thought it would be fun to put faces to the names and exaggerated 40 times seen on all of the recruiting websites. But instead I feel like one of the tools featured on the Rivals.com commercial. (For the record, Rivals, I don't need to know where a recruit is going before his momma does).

It seems that when NBC planned this game, they decided to flush any shame they had left after green-lighting The Biggest Loser. The overblown drama and utter seriousness of what really is just a glorified high school football game was at the same time both hilarious and embarrassing. I'll leave the irony and social implications of praising the "heart" and "dedication" of 18-year-old football players in front of a crowd of 18-year-old Army soldiers awaiting deployment to Iraq to someone else, and just point out some of my favorite highlights from the broadcast.

DeSean Jackson's hot dog 4.5-yard dive into the endzone from the 5-yard line (he broke free and was about to score when he decided to somersault into the endzone, came up a foot short, hit the ground and fumbled the ball) was undoubtedly the funniest/best moment from an otherwise sloppy, mistake-filled game won by the West 35-3. But you would never guess how ugly the game was by listening to the praise raining down from the announcers booth. I lost track of how many different players "stood out from the rest" and once the Boss Hog himself, Tom Lemming, began offering up his professionally amateur opinion, the word hyperbole surrendered. I'm pretty sure that half of the NFL Pro Bowl team was used in comparisons to kids still waiting to get lucky on their senior prom. (Okay, so I typed hoping, realized they are already playing football on national TV, and changed it to waiting.)

The only thing that could have topped the high-school-senior-to-Strahan comparisons arrived in the form of Jamie Newberg and his up-to-the-second Recruiting Top 10. Considering he was told all of the choices of the kids before the game (do you think they just happen to have the correct college fight song cued up over the PA?) his "predictions" early in the show weren't exactly a result of his keen insight. Seriously though, did we really need to know that Iowa jumped from outside the top 10 before the game, to 7 or 8 sometime in the 2nd quarter, before settling in at 4 at the end of the game? Why don't we just update the college basketball Top 25 on a bucket-by-bucket basis? Sadly, it's extraneous fluff like this that highlights the ugly business-and-bottom-line-aspect of recruiting, in what should be an otherwise fun day for these guys to just play a football game. If you need to fill the broadcast, how about a story about one of the kids' personal lives outside of football? You know, to humanize them a bit? They're not all just season stats and combine results. Come on NBC, I've watched the Olympics. That sort of stuff is your bag, baby.

Still, after yet another painfully tacky halftime performance and extended Arena League promo, I watched as Don Juan Hord chose Notre Dame -- proudly, and in coherent, complete sentences -- unlike some of the other guys on the show (we'll chalk it up to nerves, Ryan Bain). He joins previous All-American Bowl alumni like Carlos Campbell, Zach Giles, Chris Frome, Nate Schiccatano, Anthony Fasano, Brian Mattes, Jake Carney, Marcus Freeman, Scott Raridon, Bob Morton, James Bonelli, Maurice Stovall, Rhema McKnight, Travis Leitko, Brady Quinn, Travis Thomas, John Carlson, John Sullivan, Victor Abiamiri, Tom Zbikowski, Ambrose Wooden, Ryan Harris, John Kadous, Terrail Lambert, and Anthony Vernaglia.

Let's just hope that the All-American Bowl isn't the last bowl game that DJ Hord wins. Now if you excuse me, the All-American Bowl high school juniors -- yes, juniors -- combine results should be posted on the web soon.

* David Nelson's level of commitment to Notre Dame seems to be changing by the minute. Where's Jamie Newberg when you really need him.

Friday, January 14, 2005

Pleased to Meet Me | by Jay

The image “http://2walls.com/IMAGES/MUSIC/cd_replacements_meet3.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.We've been up and running for just over a month now, and we're curious who's out there reading.

If you have a second, drop us a comment (link below) to say hello.



Grab Bag | by Jay

Just a few items to keep us going through the weekend.

Herring on the way

I'm sure you've seen it by now, but Florida safety prospect Ray Herring didn't simply commit to ND yesterday, he shot out of a cannon, with an infectious enthusiasm and effusive praise for all things Irish:
I WANT TO BE A MEMBER OF THE FIGHTING IRISH! Notre Dame is a special place. A really special place. The people are genuine and you can tell they truly care. The campus is spectacular and the coaching staff is second to none.

02raytalksaboutlettersCoach Weis has 26 years of experience, 15 in the NFL, and 3 Super Bowl rings. The assistants he has brought in are absolutely incredible. On his staff he has brought in three former college head coaches, former NFL assistant coaches and college coaches with great experience. My position coaches include Coach Bill Lewis, who coached the Miami Dolphins secondary for nine years, and Coach Brian Polian, who is young, enthusiastic, and has a strong resume coaching in college. Coach Polian is also the coach who has been recruiting me and his fire and passion for Notre Dame is contagious.

Notre Dame has an overall graduation rate of 99% among its football program, the best coaches in college football, an extremely talented team whose program boasts an unmatched record of success, history and tradition.

With a national schedule of top ranked opponents, national television and radio broadcasts, all combined with the best fans in the entire nation, how could anyone not jump at the chance to be a part of the Notre Dame family?

I spoke with Coach Weis today and told him that I wanted to call OUR other recruits and get them to South Bend. So, if you're a Notre Dame recruit and haven't committed to us yet, get ready because Ray's gonna be calling ya!

Come to Notre Dame, get one of the best educations in the nation, at the best university in the nation, with the best team and coaches in the nation! Come to Notre Dame and help us bring home a 12th National Championship to the Irish fans...maybe more! Oh yeah, one more thing... GO IRISH!!!

Great stuff from a great kid. And it's refreshing to see such unbridled optimism from a kid who hasn't even enrolled yet, especially in light of what some of our prominent alums in the media spewed forth about ND in the past weeks. As the Weis era unfolds, the future seems more and more sanguine, and statements like Aaron Taylor's "the mystique is dead!" harden and crinkle into what they really are: cheap, smug, self-serving brownie points. Taylor, Rocket and even Golic (to a lesser extent) jumped off at the first stop when they thought the bus was going to break down; instead, our ride's been revamped, retooled, and tricked-out. Right about now, I bet they're wishing they'd stayed on board.


Along Those Lines

From today's Chicago Tribune:
January 13, 2005, 10:52 PM CST

Another familiar face may be returning to Notre Dame. Wide receiver Tim Brown, the most recent of the Irish's seven Heisman Trophy winners (1987), might join the staff of new football coach Charlie Weis, himself a graduate of the university.

Notre Dame associate athletic director John Heisler confirmed that Brown was on campus on Thursday. Brown did not meet with Weis, who is in New England preparing for the Patriots' playoff game Sunday against Indianapolis. Heisler did confirm that Brown and Weis have spoken on the phone.

If Brown were to return, it likely would be as the team's director of player development. Though he wouldn't go on the road to recruit, he still could play a significant role in convincing top-tier players to commit to Notre Dame after they arrive for a campus visit.
I guess Tim didn't get the Aaron Taylor memo about dead mystique and all that.

Now I'm not usually given to irrational exuberance in this forum, but my reaction to Tim Brown returning home would go something like this.


An Oldie but a Goodie

While we wait for Fox to dream up a recruiting reality show for prime time TV (next week on The Recruit...David Nelson's got a surprise, and you won't BELIEVE what it is!) here's an old story about one of our favorite punching bags.
During my junior year in 1999, two of my female friends from Welsh Hall went off-campus to the 7-Eleven Store on the corner of Edison and Jefferson. They were shopping for snacks when they heard someone in the rear of the store banging on the hot dog machine (you know the kind -- the multi-pronged device capable of cooking up nasty 7-Eleven nostril-dogs at any time of day).

It turns out to be Bob Davie, who was having problems getting the little plastic door open.

According to my friends, when his last attempt to get the door open failed, Bob slammed his fist against the side of the machine and bellowed, "I swear, this whole town is trying to f--- me!"
I don't know what's funnier...Boob's interjection or the fact that he was noshing on hot dogs from 7-Eleven. I always wondered if anyone actually ate those rotating chunks of hardened grizzle. Now we know. (Thanks to Buddy Jeans over on NDN for the laugh).

Wednesday, January 12, 2005

Weekend at Charlie's | by Mike

Last recuiting season, college football fans around the nation got many laughs from a series of articles written by a highly coveted defensive recruit from Florida. The recruiting diary expressed Willie Williams' wide-eyed wonder ("He took me to the hotel. This place was beautiful, nicest place I've ever stayed. It was called The Radisson."), but also helped make Williams' criminal past public knowledge. Williams was eventually welcomed with open arms at Miami.

Before Willie's run-in with the law on his Florida trip, a few posters expressed concern that Williams' coach would allow a newspaper to exploit his player's naivete. Either a coach or parent should have stepped in and either pulled the plug on the series, or demanded some form of editorial control over the series.

This year, another highly coveted defensive recruit from Florida has kept a recruiting diary for a local publication. However, safety prospect Ray Herring demonstrates what the recruiting process looks like when a recruit has a strong support system in place. His latest entry also sheds light on the recruiting experience at Notre Dame under Coach Weis.

The entire article is definitely worth reading. Ray discusses the new facilities, his meetings with academic advisors, and how former WR Bobby Brown, currently enrolled at ND Law after a brief stint in the NFL, helps out with recruiting.

Many passages should make Irish fans optimistic about their chances with Ray (who cancelled his previously scheduled visit to Tennessee after returning from Notre Dame). For example, he states:

We then broke up into groups and toured the facilities. My group went right to the stadium. We walked into the locker room and I thought to myself about all of the great players who have walked through here before me, players like Jonny Lujack, Paul Hornung, Joe Montana, Joe Theismann, Bob Golic, Rocket Ismail, Tim Brown and Jerome Bettis, to name just a few.

All of the great coaches like Knute Rockne, Frank Leahy, Ara Parseghian and Lou Holtz. All of the National Championships, all of the All-Americans, all of the tradition. I thought to myself, how blessed am I? The locker room has big open wooden lockers and a big ND in the carpet in the middle of the floor.

I met the head football equipment manager Henry Scroope who had all of the NFL jerseys of their former players hanging at the lockers. It was amazing how many there were!

It is tempting to interpret Ray's comments as evidence of Weis's recruiting prowess. While I believe Weis will ultimately prove to be an excellent recruiter, Ray appears to be the type of recruit Notre Dame always does well with. He is humble, with an appreciation for the opportunities his athletic talent has created for him ("how blessed am I?"). His comments about academics seem far more sincere than your average recruit ("It was cool because you can tell that everybody loves the football program at Notre Dame but nobody is going to give you anything just because you are on the football team. You're expected to earn your degree just like every student there. That is important because I won't be able to play football forever!").

However, the most encouraging sign for Irish fans is the great parenting from which Ray has benefitted. An earlier Florida Today article profiled Ray's relationship with his father. Just as Kory Minor's mother did, Mr. Herring has helped Ray appreciate that he is making a forty-year, rather than four-year, decision.

"He tells me to always have a backup plan," the younger Herring said. "The best advice he has given me is to put education first because at any point in life, football can be taken away. We talk almost every day and I've never, ever seen him get down. He keeps me going. I look at him and he's never quit, so I have no reason to."

Ray already comes from a great family. Hopefully, he will soon find out what it is like to be a part of the Notre Dame family, too.

Tuesday, January 11, 2005

Odds and Sods | by Teds

Introductions

As it pertains to Jay's piece immediately below, the first thing that jumped out at me was the difference in the breadth of Malloy's opening remarks for the two coaches. If nothing else, the considerably more brief introduction of Weis is consistent with Malloy's reduced (and quite possibly nonexistant) role in this latest search, not to mention his impact on the prospects of the University in general with his retirement rapidly approaching.

In retrospect, his effusive praise of Willingham last time around practically screams out to the world that the decision was his baby, an attempt to put his own personal stamp on the football program and its future course. Malloy briefly hits on the topic of "social change", instilling in every columnist from Anchorage to Zanesville whatever motivation they weren't already possessed with to prattle on about everything other than the wins and losses themselves. And as noted, there's all sorts of idealistic and subjective mumbo-jumbo about what amounts to little more than a vision of Notre Dame through Malloy-colored glasses. His appreciation for and stewardship of the Irish football program was sorely lacking from the outset of his reign, and this moment in history stands as the most damning evidence of Malloy's shortcomings in those terms.

His appearance in the Weis introduction press conference was little more than an opportunity to pay respects to an outgoing president, as well as offering televised proof of the passing of the torch to Father Jenkins. Suffice it to say that those who care deeply about the University and its football team are better for it.


Weis' Lays Down the Law

Weis opened his press conference last Friday with a monologue directed toward the media figures who had gathered to cover the event. The subsequent reaction to those comments has swung wildly from enthusiastically supportive to caustically dismissive and most everywhere in between. A couple things should be made clear on the subject.

First of all, it's Weis' team now. He's the one will ultimately be trumpeted as a legend or branded as an incapable washout based on Notre Dame's performance, so I don't find it unacceptable that he'd desire to establish some ground rules. And better that he communicates this in an upfront manner now than to take some reporter to task at a later date for a violation of Weis policy that wasn't clear from the outset. Weis' statements might have been unusual, but that doesn't necessarily mean that they will prove to be unfair, nor that the Irish team will be inappropriately inaccessable to those covering them.

Further, the Irish football program gets more media attention than any other on the college landscape and ranks among the most prominent in all of sports. Weis' comments mark him as someone who recognizes the saturation of coverage that Notre Dame attracts, specifically the potential pitfalls associated with that level of coverage. He's obviously not blind to the role that the media plays and the sort of impact it can have on a football team in performance as well as perception. That he considered the subject important enough to broach at the outset of his first regular press conference as Irish head coach is a undoubtedly positive sign. What sort of coach at this level would treat the relations between his team and the media as if he were doing nothing more than opening the gates to an amusement park?

I'm also getting a kick out of the notion that Weis has offered an example in this instance of just how unfit he is to be a big-time head coach. This is a man who has spent the last fifteen years of his life coaching exclusively in New York and Boston, home to quite possibly the two most aggressive and unfriendly media klatches on the face of the earth. Certainly, Weis hasn't had the sort of direct exposure to them that he'll have with reporters as Notre Dame's coach, nor will that target on his back now be much of a carryover. But Weis is undoubtedly an intelligent man, and I have no reason to think that he hasn't accumulated as much knowledge of the media, their tendencies and how to effectively deal with them as he has how to read and break down NFL defenses.

In summary, to conclude that Weis is in over his head based expressly on those remarks is more ludicrous than the remarks themselves.


Nuts and Bolts on the Q&A

There's already been a great deal of dissection of Weis' comments on Friday, and he's certainly hitting on many of the points that Irish fans have been thirsting to hear from their head coach for some time: finding a balance between coaching ability and recruiting skill in his staff, attracting coaches with past connections to ND, tailoring schemes to suit the strengths and weaknesses of his personnel, finding football players and not necessarily combine warriors and winning in the near future with no excuses or references to rebuilding.

One of the remarks I found interesting that hasn't been discussed is Weis' breakdown of prospective players into "linemen" and "skill guys". It seems that high school players are often inappropriately pigeonholed long before they're done developing, and it's not unusual to hear Tom Lemming or some other recruiting analyst speak authoritatively about what these kids are capable of achieving at the next level. But most of them are 17 years of age at the time of recruitment, and placing a ceiling on their potential as football players doesn't make sense given the important years of higher-quality instruction and physical growth still ahead.

Someone with Weis' track record for player development and who has worked at the high school, college and professional levels of football at various points in his career probably understands this better than the average coach. So when he speaks in general terms about "linemen" versus "skill guys", Weis impresses me as a coach who will likely be more open to change and different applications of potential than many others in his position might. If nothing else, it should be interesting to see the makeup of the Irish roster a year from now, specifically how many of the incumbent players will have switched positions between now and then. In the long run, I expect a significant number of conversions.

The other comment that struck me which hasn't received much coverage is his praise of line coaches John Latina and Jappy Oliver as "tough guys". Notre Dame's offensive lines have often been maligned over the past decade as underperforming, inconsistent and generally lifeless units. The defensive line seemed to perk up the past several seasons under the direction of Bob Davie holdover Greg Mattison, but this has also been a trouble spot for the team at certain points in recent years.

I won't go so far as to say that every football game is won and lost in the trenches, but a team most certainly can make up for clear deficiences in athleticism and performance on the fringes of the field by consistently beating its opponent up front off the snap. And although talent undoubtedly plays a role in who wins those types of battles, there's also a great deal to be said for the line that plays with more passion and a sense of urgency. So compared to the perceived attitude of Willingham and many of his assistants, it's refreshing to hear Weis talk frankly about "tough guys...who like to coach the guys tough." Perhaps it also ushers in a return to the program's fabled roots, when Irish football teams would rather bury their opponents three feet deep in the turf than engage them in an impromptu track meet.

In closing, it occurs to me that one of the specific passages of Malloy's introductory speech from January 1, 2002, which was most worthwhile and resonant ("(The Notre Dame job) takes a person who knows himself well, who is not acceptably sensitive, who can speak straightforwardly, who is not trying to impress the masses, but simply do a good job.") describes Weis much more appropriately than it did the coach Malloy happened to be hiring for the job that day.

Friday, January 07, 2005

Warm-up Acts | by Jay

Coach Weis had a brief press conference today, and it was a hoot. After admonishing the reporters about the new way of doing business ("If I start reading those anonymous quotes now, you're shut down...I will never say another word to you...So let's make sure we understand what the terms are walking in the door" -- BGI has the rest of the smackdown) Charlie went on to answer a few questions on his assistant coaching staff, building a team, the state of recruiting, and various other matters of great import (like which Super Bowl ring he was wearing. Actually, he gave a great answer on that: "The most recent one").

Listening to Charlie speak, you get the distinct impression that at any given time, he's got a bunch of things going on in his mind. He repeats himself some, he cuts sentences short, he rambles a bit, but he's always talking, and always thinking. Nothing seems prefabricated or overly considered; it's a garrulous, ongoing riff, as expansive and ungainly as a herd of cattle moving quickly over the plains. Yet in all the dust that's being kicked up, in every half-phrase and rambling sentence, there's a point to be made, an idea to impart, a command to give, or a moment of self-deprecation. You're getting it straight, honest, and unfiltered, right off the cuff. It's refreshing.

Anyway, the occasion provoked me to go back and read the introductory press conferences of Weis, Willingham, O'Leary, and Davie. Now, by point of comparison, it's quite easy to make kneejerk judgments based on isolated soundbites between say, Weis and Willingham, who share about as much in speaking style and charm as Jackie Gleason and a grocery checkout clerk. Juxtaposing the two leads to a lot of cheap criticisms at Willingham's expense: in comparison, and with the benefit of hindsight, Willingham seems like a real dud. Perhaps we're clouded by his crummy brand of football -- I can remember a time when Willingham was praised for his succinctness and seriousness of purpose -- but now, it all seems like a whitewash, the hollow platitudes of a politician or a high school principal.

The image “http://newsinfo.nd.edu/assets/monkjenkinsbig.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.One of the other things that strikes you upon reading the transcripts is the vastly different language used when the coaches were introduced (whether it was by Monk, Kevin White, or Father Jenkins). The intro of Ty is couched in terms of academic and spiritual achievement, with Monk expounding at length about all the non-football aspects of the Notre Dame head coaching job: family, academic performance, "appropriateness", residentiality. Monk basically delivered his stump normally reserved for the Sports Business Council, the NCAA committee on gambling, or the Society of Christian Ethics. You'd think he was introducing a new team chaplain, not a football coach.

With Charlie's introduction, you got the broad strokes, and then it was down to business. It's brief, almost terse: Monk says about two things, Jenkins hits the main theme ("Acting with integrity, giving our students a superb education and excelling on the field"), and White goes over his coaching credentials. The new regime seems to be saying: enough speeches, forget the platitudes and save the political grandstanding. Let's get this party started right.

Ty Willingham Introduction, 1/1/02

FATHER MALLOY: Happy New Year to you all. What a great way to start. I am very excited about this day and I'd like to offer a few comments if I could before inviting our Athletic Director Kevin White to come up to introduce our new football coach.

Yesterday I spent some quality time with Coach Tyrone Willingham, his wife Kim, and his three wonderful children and I can tell you this is a great family and we are just delighted to be able to welcome them into the Notre Dame family.

Coach Willingham and I had a chance to talk about all those fundamental things that have been an integral part of the history of Notre Dame as an institution of its athletic programs and of its football program.

We talked about what it takes to win consistently in this kind of academic environment. We talked about the things that we expect of our coaches and of our student athletes, whether it is with regard to academic performance or behavior, or the way in which they represent the University of Notre Dame.

This is a kind of occasion which has the potential to be described entirely as a kind of social statement and surely there's an element of that to it.

What I want to say very straightforwardly that the reason that Coach Willingham was chosen after a very exhaustive search was because he was the very best coach who was appropriate for Notre Dame and all it represents.

We heard over and over again from very knowledgeable people, about college and professional football, that he was one of the most highly regarded coaches out there. That he had done an outstanding job in circumstances where very few had achieved the same level of success. That he ran a program that was exemplary in terms of the success rate of his student athletes moving on not simply to graduation, but to meaningful lives, including lives of leadership in every walk of life.

That he held his student athletes to the same standards that he held himself. And if there's anything that you hear over and over again about this man, is that he is a person of integrity who lives by the highest standards and really tries to live an example to those he's instructing.

He's not only a good family man, but he's tried to induce a sense of family among his players to be firm but understanding, to try to hold them to high standards without embarrassing them in the process.

This is a very difficult job, maybe one of the most difficult jobs in the sporting area and yet there's a lot of rewards that go along with it as well. It's a high-profile position. It takes a person who knows himself well, who is not acceptably sensitive, who can speak straightforwardly, who is not trying to impress the masses, but simply do a good job.

We talked about all of that. I felt a great rapport and a great sense of confidence. I really believe, despite all the speculation, much of which was idle and uninformed, this process has resulted in the selection of an outstanding coach for Notre Dame, who knows that we have a high bar of excellence here, that he recognizes what it means to work within an outstanding academic institution, for a meaningful education is our first priority, that he's comfortable and excited about working in a religiously affiliated school, where we use God language regularly and meaningfully and in which we expect that one of the things that will happen to the young people entrusted to our care, is that they will grow in the life of faith as well.

So I can say once again, it's a great new year. I am happy to be able on this occasion to welcome into our midst, our new football coach, who I think will do an outstanding job and I pledge that we will do everything we can to support him and to give him the resources necessary to succeed.

He knows what our standards are. He embraces them. He's excited about being at Notre Dame and we're so excited about him agreeing to be our new football coach.

Charlie Weis Introduction, 12/13/04

FATHER MALLOY: Welcome to you all. I am pleased to be able to welcome our new football coach. He has great pedigree, not only as a Notre Dame graduate, but in terms of his achievements in the professional ranks. I want to say to him, to Coach Weis, you have my whole-hearted support. We are really pleased to welcome you and your family back to our community and I encourage every member of the broader Notre Dame community to give you the support that you deserve.

I'd like to now welcome to the podium my successor, father John Jenkins, who I am confident will do an outstanding job and who will be working with our new coach in the years ahead. John?

FATHER JENKINS: Thank you. At the University of Notre Dame, the success in our football program consists of three things: Acting with integrity, giving our students a superb education and excelling on the field.

Meeting all of these goals is a tremendous challenge. But I believe we have found a person in Charlie Weis who can lead us to such multifaceted success. Charlie is a Notre Dame graduate, an offensive coordinator of the New England Patriots and holder of three Super Bowl rings; a man of tremendous character and a man who understands and embraces the highest ideals of Notre Dame. Charlie was clearly the most impressive candidate we interviewed, and I could not be happier that he will be the new football coach at the University of Notre Dame.


Thursday, January 06, 2005

In a Nutshell | by Jay

From Pepper Johnson's book Won For All, about the 2001-02 Patriots' Super Bowl run, here's an excerpt that puts a nice little wrapper around a lot of things we've been hearing about how Charlie calls a game:
(p. 86) What Charlie Weis does is try to keep you on your toes and spread the ball around as much as possible. He does it with a running attack that will run at you and around you with counter plays and draws. He will change personnel; in fact he's notorious for it. He'll go from three wide receivers to four, two halfbacks, one tailback, two or three tight ends. Week by week he tries to stay away from normal tendencies...He does a great job that way.
Does this mean we won't be seeing the bubble screen 5+ times per game? Say it ain't so.

Along these lines, I don't know how many of you have a subscription to Irish Eyes, but there was a post on the members board yesterday that was absolutely hilarious (you'll need a membership to read the whole thing). Apparently some fan picked up on Diedrick's simplistic scheme for audibles last year and began predicting play after play to the delight and amazement of the people around him in the stands. Every time Quinn would audible, this guy would know exactly what was coming. This went on for a couple of games, and seeing no change, the guy thought he better alert Bill that even the schmoes in row 30 were able to tell what was coming next. He emailed Diedrick after the Washington game, and to his surprise, Bill actually wrote back, claiming that the guy was wrong and the schemes were impossible to predict. Of course, for the next game, Diedrick switched everything up, and they never used that audible scheme for the rest of the year.

Check out the original post if you get a chance. It's a stitch.

Taking the red pill | by Dylan




Let me tell you why you're here. You're here because you know something. What you know you can't explain, but you feel it. You've felt it your entire life, that there's something wrong with the world. You don't know what it is, but it's there, like a splinter in your mind, driving you mad.


What is there to say? For me, the events of the past month have taken on a sense of unreality. Pat, Michael, Sean, and Jay have summarized, analyzed, and eulogized below. This week, I think the operative word is crystallize. Two events have splashed cold water on my face and have brought the world into clearer focus. The haze is lifting. For the past 10 years we’ve felt it. We know it’s wrong, but it’s been so long, we’ve come to wonder if that isn’t the way the world really is. We’ve doubted. Well, the time for doubt has passed.

Have you ever had a dream, Neo, that you were so sure was real? What if you were unable to wake from that dream? How would you know the difference between the dream world and the real world?

Watching USC, defunct (irrelevant, even) four short years ago, mercilessly dismantle the best college football program of the past five years should provide a glimpse of the possible (even probable) for Irish fans everywhere. Powerhouse programs left for dead come back. USC has just displaced the previous phoenix, Oklahoma. USC’s Orange Bowl performance was awe inspiring. Speed, strength, and execution. Big plays on offense, defense, and special teams. Three years ago, this team was closing the books on a three-year stretch during which they won seventeen and lost nineteen. Since then they have won thirty-six and lost three. They have won twenty-two in a row. My point is, USC’s resurgence is not a dream. It is the real world. Things can also change very quickly for Notre Dame. In fact, they already have. We have taken our first steps back into the real world.


Spoon boy: Do not try and bend the spoon. That's impossible. Instead... only try to realize the truth.
Neo: What truth?
Spoon boy: There is no spoon.
Neo: There is no spoon?
Spoon boy: Then you'll see, that it is not the spoon that bends, it is only yourself.


The staff assembled by Charlie Weis, and the work already being done by that staff, is so radically different from anything that’s happened in our program in such a long time, it’s bracing. Younger fans may not understand. Banished is the notion that our football coach needs to be an arm of the Notre Dame Brand Protection Team. Our football coach is a football coach. He has hired a staff of freakish experience. They are going to go out and find football players and they are going to teach them to play football and they are not going to apologize to anyone. Nor are they going to subtly promote the idea that success in the classroom mitigates failure on the field. That is the paradigm we had settled into; one in which academic excellence and winning percentage were inversely proportional and eternally irreconcilable. To mix the metaphor a little, we were encouraged to believe that resistance was futile, that the natural order had ceased to be. Trying to comprehend why this current, ongoing shock to the system didn’t happen years ago is a spoon that we can’t bend, so now, there is no spoon.

Notre Dame is unplugged from The Monktrix, and it’s time to kick some ass.

Wednesday, January 05, 2005

Irrelevant? | by Jay

You probably saw this earlier today, but in case you didn't...

Per UND.com, who seems to have a newfound (and very welcome) sense of self-promotion:

Irish Remain College Football's Top Draw On Television

Six Notre Dame games among 25 highest-rated network contests in 2004.

Jan. 5, 2005

NOTRE DAME, Ind. - The University of Notre Dame football team in 2004 once again received more network television exposure and played in more highly-rated games than any other program in college football.

Notre Dame played in the highest-rated network game of the 2004 regular season (and the highest rated regular-season game overall in two seasons) in its '04 regular-season finale at USC. That game, televised by ABC Sports, received a 6.3 Nielsen rating and was seen in 6.898 million households, making it the most-watched nationally broadcast regular-season college football game on network television in '04, according to figures in the Dec.27, 2004-Jan. 2, 2005 issue of Street & Smith's SportsBusiness Journal.

Overall, Notre Dame played in six games that ranked among the top 25 highest-rated network telecasts - and no other school played in more than five (Tennessee and Georgia each played in five). Here are the other five games involving Notre Dame:

• Notre Dame's victory over Michigan on Sept. 11 on NBC Sports ranked ninth with a 4.0 Nielsen rating (4.384 million households).

• Notre Dame's victory at Tennessee on Nov. 6 on CBS Sports earned a 3.4 (3.75 million) and ranked 11th.

• The Oct. 2 Notre Dame-Purdue game on NBC received a 2.5 rating (2.719 million) and ranked 22nd.

• The Nov. 13 Notre Dame-Pittsburgh game on NBC received a 2.4 (2.578 million) and ranked 24th.

• Notre Dame's Sept. 25 victory over Washington on NBC earned a 2.3 (2.518 million) and ranked 25th.

Meanwhile, Notre Dame played twice during the '04 regular season on ESPN -- and both those telecasts rated among the top 14 most-watched regular-season college football games on cable television this past year.

The Sept. 18 Notre Dame victory at Michigan State in prime time on ESPN earned a 2.6 coverage area rating (2.326 million households) and ranked ninth among games on cable. The Irish season opener Sept. 4 at BYU received a 2.5 rating (2.197 million) and ranked 14th.

Once again in 2004, Notre Dame was the only school in the country to have all 11 of its regular-season games carried by either NBC (six), CBS (two), ABC (one) or ESPN (two).

Including the Insight Bowl carried on ESPN, Notre Dame now has a remarkable streak of 148 consecutive games (more than 12 full seasons) that have been carried by either NBC (80), ABC (42), CBS (14) or ESPN (12). You have to go all the way back to the 1992 season to find a Notre Dame football games that was not shown by either NBC, ABC, CBS or ESPN.

As my grandfather-in-law once said, "He who tooteth not his own horn, often finds his horn not tooted."

Tuesday, January 04, 2005

Experience, experience, experience | by Pat

When und.com announced the rest of Charlie Weis's coaching staff, the first thing that struck me was the incredible amount of experience in the group. Reading the first two paragraphs of the release, it's hard not to be impressed by the collective accomplishments of Notre Dame's new football coaches:

Twenty-five seasons of experience as a collegiate head coach. Twenty-nine seasons as an offensive or defensive coordinator (plus 21 more as a special teams or recruiting coordinator).

Twelve seasons as a National Football League assistant coach (including five playoff appearances).

Seventy-seven postseason bowl appearances. Forty-two bowl victories. Forty-five finishes in the final Associated Press top 25 rankings.

Digging a bit deeper, I thought it would be interesting to see just how much of that experience was at major (read: BCS) conferences. Obviously, being a coordinator or head coach at a school in the SEC or Big 10 is more impressive than a school in the MWC or some other smaller conference. Breaking it down by conference looks something like this:
  • ACC - 3 years as head coach; 15 years total experience
  • Big 10 - 10 years total experience
  • Big 12 - 9 years total experience
  • Big East - 13 years total experience
  • Pac 10 - 9 years total experience
  • SEC - 7 years as head coach; 19 years as coordinator; 58 years total experience
  • Notre Dame - 2 years as coordinator; 2 years total experience
The depth of experience across all of the BCS conferences is impressive. Much was made of the Pac 10-oriented nature of Willingham's staff, and it appears that Weis's guys, while SEC-heavy, have had jobs at all of the major conferences across the college landscape. Not only will this help in recruiting nationally, it should also alleviate concerns about Weis's relative inexperience in coaching college football.

And when the NFL experience of Lewis and Parmalee (to say nothing of Weis himself) is thrown in...well, that's just downright unfair.


Monday, January 03, 2005

All Aboard | by Jay

Following up on our coaching rundown, it looks like the official assistant hires release from the ND SID will be out soon, and the AP already has a copy of it. The final list, with their official titles, looks like this:
David Cutcliffe - Assistant Head Coach (offense) and Quarterbacks

Mike Haywood - Offensive Coordinator, Runningbacks

Rob Ianello - Recruiting Coordinator, Receivers

John Latina - Offensive Line

Bill Lewis - Assistant Head Coach (defense) and Defensive Backs

Rick Minter - Defensive Coordinator, Linebackers

Jappy Oliver - Defensive Line

Bernie Parmalee - Special Teams, Tight Ends

Brian Polian - Assistan Defensive Backs, Special Teams


Weis adds another coach | by Pat

A new name apparently added to Charlie Weis' staff is another former Dolphin assistant, Bernie Parmalee. It appears that Rich Bisaccia will stay in Tampa Bay with Jon Gruden and that Parmalee will take his place as the new special teams coach (and coach TEs as well). As the only assistant coach with no college coaching experience and only three years of coaching experience total, Parmalee appears as a bit of a mystery hire. So what can we expect from him?

Parmalee is well-known to Dolphin fans for his seven years as a running back, and also his unique story about how he made it to the NFL. After graduating from Ball State, Parmalee spent a year out of football working as a cashier in a bowling alley and on a UPS loading dock. In 1992, he made the Dolphins as a free agent and worked his way up from a special teams player to the team's leading rusher in 1994 and 1995. After he lost the starting running back job, he continued to contribute as the special teams captain in 1998 and 1999. In 2000, the New York Jets signed Parmalee to help out their special teams and this is the year his path crossed with Charlie Weis, who was the Jets offensive coordinator that year.

After retiring from football in 2001, Parmalee joined the Dolphins for the 2002 season as an assistant under special teams coach Keith Armstrong and as an offensive assistant. Some Irish fans might recall that Armstrong was the linebackers and special teams coach at Notre Dame in 1993. During the two years that Parmalee assisted Armstrong on special teams, the Dolphins did not allow a punt or kickoff to be returned for a touchdown. This past year he was promoted to running backs coach and later, when offensive coordinator Joel Collier stepped down due to illness, he shifted over to tight ends coach, which was fine for Miami Dolphins TE Randy McMichael:
"He keeps telling us how good a tight end he was," McMichael said. "I believe it
because he's a good coach and he's really helping us out a lot. He knows football. That's the thing about Bernie -- he's a good football coach, not just a tight ends coach."
What all this means for Irish fans isn't entirely clear. Parmalee has special teams experience both as a coach and as a veteran who at one point was signed specifically for his special teams experience and leadership. In fact, Parmalee received some high praise from Bill Parcells when he signed with the Jets.
"I've coached against him for nearly seven years," said Jets coach Bill Parcells. "I know Bernie better than I know some of the guys on my own team. He's what I'd consider a very good all-around football player. I'm pretty well aware of what he can do. He's an excellent special teams player and he knows what to do out there on the field."
Parmalee is a bit different from the other assistants on Charlie Weis' staff in that he is the only one with limited coaching experience and no recruiting experience. However, he does have the advantage of being a recent NFL player with multiple years of experience playing on special teams. Whether that translates to excellent special teams coaching isn't immediately obvious, but after playing in the NFL for nine years, Parmalee has had exposure to many successful coaches. He played under head coaches Don Shula, Jimmy Johnson, and Bill Parcells. Also, while in Miami as special teams captain, he played under special teams coach Mike Westoff, who in 2000 was named NFL Special Teams Coach of the Year. Parmalee's path from the UPS loading docks to starting running back in the NFL also has helped to shape his coaching style.
“I’ve worked for everything,” said Parmalee, 34. “Nothing ever came easy. I’m
going to let [the players] know the route I took and have them stay focused and
play hard.”
When it comes to recruiting it appears that Parmalee is a novice, but his youth and NFL experience should be great assests in recruiting. Like Weis, he is a Jersey native who could help out recruiting in the east coast, or he could use his connections in Miami to help recruit Florida.

Of course, the key to recruiting is persistence and out-hustling the competition, and everything written about Parmalee suggests that he's no stranger to hard work. Perhaps Weis is taking a bit of a flier on Parmalee, but after working with him on the Jets and coaching against him the past 3 years, Weis probably has a far greater grasp on Parmalee's talents and abilities than a few google searches will turn up. Parmalee looks like a fine addition to Charlie's staff.

Bernie Parmalee Bio

Two-Hat Charlie | by Jay

Our new coach had a Patriots press conference today, and understandably, a lot of Notre Dame questions were mixed in among the Patriots' playoff chatter. The thing bounced back and forth so much, it produced this moment of unintentional humor:

Q: In your offensive philosophy, how much was drafting talent that will fit into your system versus taking what you already have and making it work?

CW: Are you talking about the Patriots?

Seems to encapsulate what must be a very confusing time for Charlie...I can't imagine trying to juggle both duties at once.

Lots of interesting tidbits were divulged, and Weis gave us a little more insight into his hiring, how things are progressing under the Dome, and what the future holds in store for ND. A few excerpts:



Q: What is your life like right now? Are you conflicted at all with being here and at Notre Dame?

CW: No, as a matter of fact, I think the most important thing that happened to me as this situation with Notre Dame went down, was I thought that character and integrity could be a question when it came to a conflict or contradiction between the two jobs. I think it was important to me personally and professionally to try to do due diligence to both jobs. I think I have been able to do that with a fairly good amount of success so far. Hopefully by February it reaps the benefits on both ends.

Q: Since you were hired at Notre Dame, have you been able to manage your time the same way you would if it hadn't come along?


CW:
I think it has been pretty close. It has just meant that my hours get pushed a little later at night. So, instead of going to bed at 10:30 or 11 [p.m.] it is [pushed back] to 2 [a.m.]. But, I think I have gone about talking about this, to my wife and my son in particular, in a training camp mentality. In training camp we go on about three hours of sleep a night, and it is because by the time we are done with the players and we meet, and then we have the scripts for the next day it is 1:30 [a.m.]. By the time you go lay down, you're getting back at 5:30 [a.m.]. So, we just felt that until February we would view it as a training camp mentality and this way you can do the right thing by the Patriots and at the same time not neglect Notre Dame.

***

Q: As far as hiring your assistant coaches, was there any kind of discussion between you and Bill [Belichick] where he has said, 'Please don't take anyone from here?'

CW: He didn't say that, but I am not taking any of the position coaches from here out of respect for Bill Belichick. Case closed. I will not take a position coach from here.

Q: How much of a benefit will it be for potential recruits to turn on the television and see you coaching the playoffs?

CW: There is good and bad there. So, let's talk about the positive first. Because I have gotten into this game late as far as Notre Dame goes, what you don't have are personal relationships [that other recruiters have] with these guys who have been schmoozing them for six months, a year or two years. You don't have those. So, when I talk to a recruit I don't try to proclaim that I am their best buddy. I just try to get right to the facts. I just try to sell Notre Dame and me because I can't talk about my relationships with them. So, where some people think of that as a glaring negative that you don't have personal relationships, every time we play it is an opportunity for guys to sit there and look at their prospective head coach. Obviously, 17- and 18-year old young men are very impressionable. I think that it could be a positive. I am certainly looking at it as a positive because I am not ready to stop playing.

Q: How much will you draw from your years both coaching at South Carolina and attending Notre Dame heading into this job?

CW: I think recruiting is always a question of personality. It is schmoozing, and that is something that I like to do. The fact that I went to Notre Dame makes it a little easier to talk to these guys about the experience of being at Notre Dame is, because I was there for four years. I think that being out of the recruiting mix doesn't necessarily mean that you won't be a front line recruiter because I enjoy it. I think the people who usually fail in recruiting are people that just don't like do it, and I am not in that case.

***

Q: How important is it to you that you finish off this season with a Super Bowl win?

CW: It is important enough that I told Notre Dame that if I couldn't do that I didn't want the job. That is how important it is. When I went through the interview process I said, 'I can't take that job if I can't finish the one I have now,' because I felt I owed it to the organization, the team, of course, but I think I also felt it [in regards] to New England in general. That is how strong my conviction was, that if it cost me the job I wasn't taking it.

Q: Was there some back and forth on that?

CW: No. It was one comment, one time. They asked me my opinion of it and I said, 'Here is my stance on that.' I just knew that if it ended up costing me the job, then so be it. But, I wasn't going to walk out on this place, not in the midst of a playoff run when hopefully something good will end up happening.

Q: Do you think a comment like that might have helped you get the job?

CW: I didn't really care to be honest with you. When I made it, it was because I meant it. I didn't say it with any intentions. I felt it was the right thing to say and do. I am not trying to endear myself with the people here. I just thought it was the right thing to do.

***

Q: One of the biggest criticisms of Notre Dame over the last decade was their inability to bring in blue chip recruits. What do you think needs to be done differently there and what do you plan on doing differently?

CW: Just give me until next recruiting season.

***

Q: Do you have time enough time to salvage this recruiting season, or is it a dead issue?

CW: I think we have made serious headway. There have been three things that have happened that have been a big plus for me personally. First of all, the last two weeks were a dead period. In a dead period you can't go out and see anyone and you only can talk to these kids one time a week for the last two weeks. So, I was the one who made every one of those phone calls to every one of those kids. So, for two weeks they heard from Notre Dame and they heard from me. Now, this week, which is the first week recruiting, I have all of my reinforcements in. So, now I have all of the coaches on the road recruiting. I will have a little time here at the end of the week, not at the beginning of the week, but I will have a little time at the end of the week to go out there and be able to meet them and their families before I come and shoot right back here. You know, shoot out, shoot back. But, at least they will be able to meet me face to face and be able to decide whether this ugly face is the guy they want to be playing for in the next four to five years.

Q: What have you done with the kids that were already there?

CW: That is the first thing that I had to do, was deal with the kids who were already there because they were in a state of flux. They were in a state of disarray. They had lost a very popular coach. I think for the two days that I was out there to start off with, I think we made head way. I am also making personal phone calls to each one of those guys now that they are home to say, 'It is 2005. Get over it. Let's move on.' So, I started in group sessions at first and I am now working to one-on-ones right now.

***
[in reference to player evaluations]

CW: Our job as coaches is, once we get them, to fit them in. Don't say, 'Well he can't do this.' Find out what he can do. That is what we do. So, I think that we as assistants all understand to take the lead of the head coach, and of course Scott in this case, because he is finding the personnel for us and then just coach them up as best we can. That is how we look at it. We never look at a player as somebody we can't use. What we try to do is maximize their strengths and minimize their weaknesses by hiding them as best we can.

***

Q: Has [your wife] been in charge of buying the house and selling the house? Those types of things?

CW: She has always been in charge. That has never changed. Unlike most other guys who think they are in charge, I understand where I fit.

Sunday, January 02, 2005

Introducing the Assistants | by Michael

Over the past couple of weeks there's been a lot of rampant speculation about who Coach Weis would tab as his assistant staff. According to various recent reports (here and here), Charlie's got his guys all lined up, and although the official announcements might not come until the bowls are over, we figured if the major media is reporting it, we might as well jump in, too. Here's a brief rundown on the (reported) new hires.



As soon as Charlie Weis was hired, a question that immediately sprang to mind was, "Who's going to coach the defense?" Weis's offensive prowess is well-known, so his most important hire is certainly going to be on the defensive side of the ball. In Rick Minter, Weis has not only found a very solid, if not spectacular defensive tactician, but a coach with some previous ND lineage.

As many Irish fans will recall, Minter served as the defensive coordinator for Holtz from 1992-93, and under him, the Irish defense was nothing short of fantastic. (Holtz hired him after watching Minter turn Ball State into a nationally-ranked, top 10 defense for two years running. Yes, Ball State). That ND '93 defensive squad might be the best Irish defense in recent memory, and I'm including the '88 squad in the mental rundown. From 92-93, the Irish had a top-10 defense and were especially stingy against the run, to the tune of allowing only 91 yards per game. Minter sent 18 players from those two teams to the pros, including memorable Irish stars such as Jeff Burris, Bobby Taylor, Bryant Young, Tom Carter, Greg Lane, and Demetrius DuBose.

Minter then became the head coach at Cincinnati, and in his 9 years there he went 53-63-1. Cincinnati was a football wasteland before Minter arrived, and while he didn't propel them into the national spotlight, he did instill some level of respectability: he took the Bearcats to four bowl games, their only postseason appearances in the past 50 years. He left Cincinnati as the school's all-time leader in wins.

Strategically speaking, Minter usually employs a 4-3 defense.
Irish fans will remember such schemes from the early 90's, when guys like Young and Flanagan clogged the middle while DuBose, Bercich, and Peterson prowled from sideline to sideline.
"My base philosophy is a four-man line," Minter said. "There are all kind of shades and overs and unders you can play, but it's going to be four down linemen and three linebackers as a base."
Minter picked up a lot of his defensive expertise from Tampa Bay Buccaneers DC Monte Kiffin, whom he served under while on Holtz's '78 Arkansas staff. He still uses a version of Kiffin's 4-3 to this day, but with heavy modifications of his own design:

“I’ve become a little bit more of a multiple front, movement, disguising, attacking — a little bit different flavor than what Monte and Pete Carroll (another Kiffin disciple) have done as they entered the NFL world,” Minter said.

Minter said his scheme allows him to be flexible. In the base four-man look, Minter can shade the line to the tight-end side or he can bring a linebacker near the line of scrimmage opposite the tight end, a variation that Kiffin and Carroll often use.

Minter also might occasionally try a three-man line — the scheme favored by Charlie Strong, Lou Holtz’s first defensive coordinator at USC.

In other situations, Minter could rush as many as seven.

“There’s not a lot of secrets out there,” Minter said. “We’ve got to mix in our zones, try to confuse the quarterbacks.”

After being fired by Cincinnati, Minter was quickly scooped up by Holtz again, and installed as the defensive coordinator at South Carolina. (Interestingly, Holtz and Minter go back even farther than the Notre Dame years. In 1978, Holtz picked Minter to be a graduate assistant at Arkansas, Minter's first big break in football). Lou clearly holds Minter in very high esteem ("Rick Minter is a winner; he'll be a great role model for our players and he'll provide outstanding leadership", said Lou upon hiring him at USC), and what better endorsement for Charlie's staff than from the last man to win a National Championship for the Irish.

Required Reading:

Minter profile

Holtz on Minter

Minter on Defense



Another hire with some Irish in his blood is new offensive coordinator Mike Haywood, a former wide receiver and defensive back for Notre Dame from 1983-86.

Michael HaywoodHaywood's been steadily moving up the coaching ranks, starting at Minnesota in 1988, with stops at Army, Ohio, Ball State, LSU, and now Texas. As befits a young coach on the rise, he's rotated among positions as he's climbed; along the way he's coached DBs, linebackers, special teams, receivers, and runningbacks. In 8 seasons at LSU he shone as the runningbacks coach, and was instrumental in developing ball carriers like Kevin Faulk (now with the Patriots), LaBrandon Toefield, and Domanick Davis. And as special teams coordinator, Haywood had LSU among the best in the SEC in nearly every statistical category.

But perhaps most important to Irish fans is Haywood's reputation as an outstanding recruiter; he's been a superstar on the recruiting trail for UT for a couple of years now, and in 2004 Haywood was tabbed by Mack Brown to be Texas's official Recruiting Coordinator. Over the past few seasons, Texas's recruiting classes have consistently ranked among the best in the country, and Haywood has a lot to do with that. That recruiting magic should translate seamlessly to ND; as a former Irish player, Haywood will be able to sell South Bend with a true passion and enthusiasm that was sorely lacking from Willingham's staff.

As Haywood himself put it:
"Really, the best reason why I'm taking the Notre Dame job is because of the opportunity to become an offensive coordinator at my alma mater, not to mention the opportunity to work with Charlie Weis and learn a new offense under him," said Texas RB coach/recruiting coordinator Michael Haywood regarding his decision to leave The University of Texas. "It's just a great opportunity for me and my family."
"Offensive Coordinator at Notre Dame" is yet another step up for Mike Haywood, and while I don't expect him to be calling the plays (I can't imagine Charlie Weis giving up those duties -- at least, not yet), the move back to his alma mater makes a lot of sense. While coaching runningbacks and designing gameplans for the Irish, Haywood will be able to learn at the feet of one of the best offensive coordinators in the game in Weis for a few years. And while Notre Dame is perhaps a stepping stone for Haywood, the Irish should greatly benefit from his recruiting and coaching acumen.

Mike Haywood bio



Most of David Cutcliffe's resume has been rehashed over the last few weeks, as his name was among the first to leak as one of Charlie's assistants.

Although he was just fired out of Ole Miss for going 4-7, don't let that worry you: Ole Miss enjoyed great success under Cutcliffe. He was the only coach in the school's history to win at least 7 games in his first five seasons, he went 44-29 in his Ole Miss career, and was fired just a year after going 10-3 and winning the Cotton Bowl.

But more important than his record at Mississippi, Cutcliffe is widely known as one of the best offensive minds in college football, and a tremendous developer of quarterbacks. He served 17 years as an assistant at Tennessee (much of that as the offensive coordinator), during which time Tennessee had one of the best offenses in the SEC (the Vols led the SEC in total offense three times, rushing offense three times, and scoring offense once). At Ole Miss he broke many school scoring records, including the most points scored in a season (391 in 2001), most touchdowns, most total offense, most rushing yards, most passing yards, and most first downs.

Cutcliffe has described his offensive philosophy thusly: examine his personnel and fit the scheme to their strengths (sound familiar?). Here's Cut on offense:
When I talk about balance - and this is where not everybody understands what that means - I'm not referring to 50/50 run and pass," Cutcliffe said. "What balance is is maintaining the ability to run and throw on any down that you choose to do so."
Coach Cut reportedly comes to us as the quarterbacks coach and an assistant head coach, and there's no doubt guys like Quinn, Wolke and Sharpley are eagerly awaiting his tutelage: he's developed the likes of Peyton and Eli Manning, Heath Schuler, Tee Martin, and Todd Helton during his career. According to Peyton:
"I was sure when he was my quarterback coach and offensive coordinator that he was sure to be a head coach one day," Peyton said. "I am glad it did not come until I had finished my college career. I am pleased that my brother Eli has had the same direction coach Cutcliffe awarded me. I know Eli and Ole Miss are benefitting from his leadership and knowledge."
The only potential downside (for us) is it looks like Notre Dame's a stepping-stone move for Cutcliffe. I'm guessing he'll bide his time for three or four years under Charlie and find another college head coaching position in relatively short order.

Required reading:

Cutcliffe bio

Cutcliffe shines in fifth year



Those who follow recruiting are overjoyed to see Mike Haywood's name among the ranks of newly hired Irish assistants. But there's another name less known but equally if not more important - Rob Ianello.

Who is Rob Ianello? Wisconsin's TE coach and recruiting coordinator. Big deal, right?

Actually, Ianello is one of the top recruiters in the country. Not only does he have experience in the SEC (Alabama), the Big-10 (two tours of duty at Wisconsin) and the Pac-10 (Arizona), but he has a reputation for recruiting success at each stop. In one article, Tom Lemming named him one of the best recruiters in the country (circa 1999). Be sure to check it out; there's also a nice little press clipping for Greg Mattison being on the wish list of ADs looking for a new head coach...okay, so some things don't always pan out.

Ianello's base is Houston. He brought kids to Arizona when he worked for Dick Tomey and John Mackovic, and now he does the same for Barry Alvarez. Thus, it shouldn't come as a surprise to see that Ianello is even recruiting Notre Dame's current verbal Kevin Washington.

Ianello is smart; "I'm not going to go into Texas against the University of Texas," Ianello said in a 1999 CNN/SI article. He knows that teams like Arizona and Wisconsin won't be able to beat out Texas for the state's best prospects, so he has been able to make a living on scouting - and landing - the talented kids whom Texas doesn't offer. And to a large extent, it has worked. But now that he's at Notre Dame, and now that he can team up with ex-Longhorn assistant Mike Haywood to recruit the best prospects in Texas, it's open season on Mack Brown.

With quality experience in the SEC, Pac-10 and Big-10, Ianello has the perfect resume for being the recruiting coordinator at Notre Dame. It won't take long until the verbals start pouring in...let's just hope there are some cornerbacks among them.

Required Reading:

The Daily Cardinal, 11/9/2004, "Badgers' Ianello Plans for Future"

CNN/SI, 8/11/1999, 1999 College Football Preview - Top 25 - Arizona



He's no Joe Moore, but Irish fans will love John Latina, the new OL coach.

Latina's bio looks great. Stops at Kansas State, Clemson and Ole Miss, and even before that, he developed a good rushing game and OL talent at Temple. It's worth reading twice. Especially that part about Temple. When Latina was there, they had two winning seasons. They've had only one since (in 1990).

The image “http://www.henrysgamecockpage.com/johnllatina.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.Additionally, it's not as though Ole Miss is bringing in lots of OL talent every year, but somehow they have managed to put together some dynamite offensive lines. Injuries and youth have not slowed them down, as evidenced in their game against Florida in '03. Wouldn't it be nice to hear this from one of our OL?
"I looked at Tre (left tackle) and said 'The ball is going over us,' " said Buckles, who plays left guard. "I told him this is where the men are made. No disrespect to Florida, but we mauled their guys."
Now, I can't withhold some evidence...namely, that Latina has been able to bring in JUCOs at Ole Miss and Kansas State (at least). But if there is one position where Notre Dame has little trouble attracting top talent, it's OL. And while Latina is not known for being a great recruiter, he doesn't need to be. From what I have read, players and families see him as a father figure, not a salesman. Given the other assistants on this staff, Latina won't be asked to be a big-time recruiter. There are other guys who can do that. In the years to come, all he needs to do is evaluate OL talent and land 3 or 4 OL in each class.

Latina will end up coaching nearly half of the offense - 5 out of 11 starters. It's a heavy burden, and Notre Dame is in very good hands with Latina. The OL on the team should be excited about playing for a coach who has experienced success wherever he's gone and possesses a track record of sending so many kids to the NFL.

Final tidbit...if you noticed, Latina coached the TEs at Pitt in 1982. Guess who was the OL coach for the Panthers that year?

Required Reading:

Gamecockcentral.com, 12/6/2004, Inside the Huddle: New Coach John Latina



Rich Bisaccia looks like the pick for special teams coach. Quick, what are the three pillars of football? Offense, defense and special teams, right?

Not according to Tyrone Willingham, who never placed an emphasis on special teams -- despite whatever lip service he'd spout in press conferences.

The image “http://www.buccaneers.com/media/photos/players/Bisaccia_Richard.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.Willingham's special teams at Stanford were average at best. Some years they'd block a few kicks, some years they'd return a few kicks for scores. But they were never consistently good, and when Willingham took the ND job, his special teams coach Phil Zacharias left for a position with the Baltimore Ravens. A golden opportunity existed to land a premier special teams assistant, and how did Willingham respond?

He hired Buzz Preston. For the last three years, Buzz Preston has coached special teams for the Irish. At least, that's what I thought. I haven't really seen results on the field to believe the players are actually being coached in the phases of special teams, and when I journeyed over to the ND athletic site, I didn't even see special teams listed as one of Preston's duties in his bio.

All that will change with Charlie Weis. All that will change with Rich Bisaccia, the new special teams assistant coach who is coming from the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.

Although Bisaccia and his charges won a Super Bowl ring in 2002, Tampa Bay's special teams sucked last year and many fans were calling for Bisaccia's head. And yet, Jon Gruden still offered Bisaccia a contract extension. In fact, Gruden had this to say in May 2003:
"Rich Bisaccia is an excellent football coach, who I really enjoy working with. He is a hard worker, extremely detail oriented and has a vast knowledge of the game. He has played a tremendous role in this organization's success."
In another article, Gruden blames personnel and attitude, not Bisaccia's schemes. In the 2003 off-season, Tampa Bay spent some money on free agents specifically to help shore up special teams, and it has apparently helped.

Last year they were 29th in punt return coverage (12.5) and 28th in kick-off return coverage (23.6). This year they are 17th in punt return coverage (8.4) and 23rd in kick-off return coverage (22.8). On the flip side, last year they were dead last in kick-off returns (18.9) and 26th in punt returns (6.9). This year, they are 6th in kick-off returns (23.6) and 24th in punt returns (7.3). While it may not be the earth-shattering numbers that Irish fans would want or expect from an incoming special teams coach, I'd strongly urge reading his bio on his special teams accomplishments from Ole Miss and Clemson. There's a reason that Jon Gruden hired him in the first place.

On top of that, do you ever think you'd hear this coming out of Buzz Preston's mouth?
"There is so much scheming (game planning) going on where other teams are looking at your punt team, your kickoff team, your extra point team..."
My favorite part of that passage from this article includes this tag regarding Bisaccia: "known for his innovative kick return blocking formations."

We're allowed to be innovative on kick returns? We're allowed to gameplan? That's shocking, since rumors on some ND message boards earlier in the year said that the players thought the special teams meetings were "a joke."

Bisaccia is an excellent hire. He has ties to Cutcliffe (Ole Miss), Latina (Ole Miss & Clemson) and Weis (South Carolina). His Ole Miss bio speaks for itself.

As far as recruiting, not much is known. He was the recruiting coordinator at Clemson, which was certainly great experience, but with recruiters like Haywood and Ianello on the staff, Bisaccia is gravy.



Our new DL coach, Jerome "Jappy" Oliver (see bio), may not be the most recognizable name in the list of new Irish assistant coaches, but he's got some impressive pedigree.

The image “http://www.flint.lib.mi.us/hallfame/04/joliver001.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.Some very good coaches have hired him throughout his career. Fisher DeBerry had him on his staff for eight seasons at Air Force. Then Lou Holtz hired him at South Carolina. Finally, after two years in Columbia he found himself without a job, and Rick Minter, who coached with him for only one year, was impressed enough to bring him to Notre Dame this year. Minter didn't have to do that, and Weis didn't have to agree to it. So Oliver must be a prety good coach. Minter went through more than a few assistant coaches (40+) during his tenure at Cincinnati so he knows a good one when he sees one...the Bearcats were a temporary stay for many an assistant on his way up the coaching ladder.

Oliver didn't have much talent to work with at Air Force, but he made the most of it. Here's a few quotes from one of his pupils, Bryce Fisher, an NFL DE who has some nice things to say about Oliver as his DL coach. In this article, Holtz echoes Fisher's sentiments when it comes to Oliver's coaching:
"I've watched Jappy coach and I want to tell you he is one of the most fundamentally sound coaches I have seen in a long long time. It is a joy to watch him with the players."
Outside of that, there really isn't much out on there on Oliver. Eight years at Air Force and four more at Vanderbilt tend to cloud your career in one of relative obscurity. Even the defensive rushing stats at South Carolina and Air Force before/during/after Oliver's time at those schools are relatively inconclusive.

As far as recruiting, Oliver's potential impact is unclear. He wasn't known as one of South Carolina's strongest recruiters, and his experience recruiting at Vanderbilt and Air Force wouldn't prepare him very well for what he'll face at Notre Dame - going up against the Miamis, Oklahomas and Michigans of college football for DL prospects. This article/bio on Oliver briefly mentions him as a "dynamic recruiter", but how much of that is South Carolina spin? His players do seem to really like him a lot, and we may not need much from a DL coach than a guy whose players love him and, more importantly, show good fundamentals.



One hire I don't get is Bill Lewis, the new DB coach. Here's his bio.

Lewis' name has been in the news of late because of the Saban hire. Apparently one of Saban's assistants called Lewis to inquire about the Dolphins' talent; the assistant was the son of Vince Dooley, who hired Lewis as defensive coordinator/DB coach in the early 80s. Lewis was not pleased to receive that phone call.

The image “http://www.hognation.net/coachpics/lewis_b.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.Without question, Lewis has some positives. He has nine years' worth of coaching experience in the NFL. The Dolphins have one of the better secondaries in the NFL, due at least in part to Lewis's expertise. He likely has recruiting ties in Georgia since he was the head coach of Georgia Tech for three years and was the defensive coordinator at Georgia for eight or nine years under Dooley. It would appear as though he could be a valuable resource as a game-planner.

But there are also negatives. He's not even the secondary coach for the Dolphins; he's the nickel DB coach. And he has either held that title for nine years, since Jimmy Johnson hired him, or he was demoted at some point during his stay in Miami. All this time, no college teams have tried to lure him out of the NFL with defensive coordinator positions. I did read that he is supposedly one of the candidates for the Arkansas DC job, but how much of that is a result of not having a job next year because Dave Wannstedt was fired?

As far as recruiting, he's 65 years old and Georgia kids may not remember him, and if they do, they probably remember his embarrassing three year stint with the Yellow Jackets that ultimately resulted in his resignation (1-8) before George O'Leary took over.

The more I read about Bill Lewis, the less I think he'd be a great fit for Notre Dame. We need a young, hungry assistant for the secondary on the upside of his career, and Bill Lewis seems to be a guy who has stuck around because of the good 'ol boys network.

Get to know Bill Lewis:

Q&A from his GaTech days

Article on GaTech hiring

ECU Memories: Bill Lewis

(Finally, how about this modern innovation known as the Internet? I can't believe I was able to find those articles on Lewis. I was actually able to find a web page that contained Lewis' first ECU recruiting class in 1989. Could it be because a certain southerner invented the internet?)



Can someone please tell me why Brian Polian as LB coach is a good hire? Quickly peruse his bio (short on accomplishments, it won't take very long).

Because of his recruiting ties in Florida? Not so sure. He's only been there for one year and he's such a young coach that he doesn't have much of a reputation (of his own) yet.

Because of his coaching experience? Eh, not entirely impressed. He coached outside LBs at Baylor and coached RBs at Buffalo for three years before moving to Central Florida to join George O'Leary's staff. How many kids has Polian sent to the NFL? Can Polian really coach LBs better than someone like Bob Simmons, who had a lot more experience?

Because of genetics? Because his father and brother are fantastic player personnel guys in the NFL? How exactly are we certain that this skill got passed down to Brian? There's absolutely no way to know one way or the other, and if Polian were hired by Tyrone Willingham, many would seriously question the hire.

Now, all that said, I like Polian as a member of this staff. There are certainly some question marks that I have about him, but I actually like him a lot. Here's why.

Brian's an up-and-comer: he's young, hungry and aggressive. Taking a wild guess, he could have easily settled for a cushy scouting position in his father's organization, but instead, he decided to establish his own name out there and do something else. With Rick Minter and Bill Lewis, the defensive staff could definitely use someone with his youthful intensity and hunger, not just for recruiting's sake but also in gameplanning. On a staff full of established professionals, my guess is that Polian is going to tirelessly work his ass off to impress his peers and hopefully move up the coaching ladder, and there's no better shortcut to promotion than plain 'ol hard work.

I'm a little concerned about his lack of experience as a LB coach, but that's where Rick Minter can really help Polian out. Not only can Minter help him coach the LBs, but Polian can also serve as an apprentice to Minter and improve his LB coaching under him. It's a win-win situation.

As briefly mentioned above, where Polian will really help out is with recruiting. The offensive staff is littered with great recruiters, but Lewis, Minter and even Oliver aren't known nor expected to be great salesmen. One has to imagine the burden of recruiting will fall heavily on Polian, who has extensive experience at Central Florida and Buffalo as the recruiting coordinator.

Polian could be a risky hire, but if this staff were a jigsaw puzzle, I see Polian as a potential missing piece. He can complement the rest of the staff - especially the defensive staff - quite nicely. He works hard and from what I've read, his attitude will jibe with the rest of the incoming staff.

Here's my favorite Polian quote, from an article linked below.
"Coaches don't decide whether or not players redshirt. Players decide whether or not they're going to redshirt. If a guy is good enough to play, most often he'll play."
There's not much out there on the internet as far as Polian goes, but here are two question & answer articles with Polian about UCF recruiting from Rivals:

February 10, 2004

August 9, 2004



In sizing everything up, I'd say Charlie's assembled a top-notch group, and what really strikes me is the breadth and diversity of their collective experience. I mean, we've got former head coaches (Cutcliffe, Minter, Lewis), young up-and-comers (Haywood, Polian), Irish legacies (Minter, Haywood), NFL warriors (Biasiccia, Lewis), recruiting wizards (Ianello, Haywood), unsung yeoman technicians (Latina, Oliver), offensive swamis (Cutcliffe, Haywood), defensive chessmasters (Minter, Lewis) and years and years of aggregate football success at all levels of the game. On any of the program prerequisites you'd like to offer up -- recruiting expertise, X's and O's, youthful energy, elderly wisdom -- it's an incredibly balanced group. All this built-in synchronicity is wonderful, and augurs well for the future.

Charlie's done well to get some coaches with long histories in the college game, and he'll be able to lean on guys like Cutcliffe and Minter as he sorts out the new challenges of moving from the NFL to the NCAA, from offensive coordinator to head coach. It looks like all facets of the football program -- offense, defense, special teams, recruiting -- are about to get a much-needed blast of fresh air.

Saturday, January 01, 2005

Quite a Year | by Pat

Without a doubt the big story of 2004 was the firing of Ty Willingham, and the subsequent hiring of Charlie Weis in December. Yet even after the ugly 5-7 season of 2003, no one would have predicted that by the end of 2004, Willingham would be wearing Husky purple and that Notre Dame would hire a guy with no head coaching experience above the high school level. So, how did we end up here? Let's take a look back on the topsy-turvy Year That Was for Irish football...

January

The year started in muted silence, as the 5-7 Irish stayed home for the holiday bowl season. The only Irish players making an appearance in a football game were Darrell Campbell, Julius Jones and Courtney Watson, who all played in the Senior Bowl. After such a disappointing season, many Irish fans turned to recruiting in the hopes that Coach Willingham could find some of those elusive "studs" (that many in the media assumed the Irish lacked) and breathe some new life into the program. By January Notre Dame had eight commitments and were still looking for a QB to back up Brady Quinn, another running back to compliment Justin Hoskins, and, stop me if you've heard this one before, a solid cornerback or two. Two recruits stood out as targets 1 and 1a for Willingham: QB Brian Brohm and RB Darius Walker. On the 20th, Brohm chose to attend Louisville, but Walker made Irish fans happy by putting on an ND hat on the 22nd. Six other recruits chose Notre Dame, but the Irish missed on some key recruits that had been targeted for a long time.

February

The big event in college football every February is National Signing Day. It's a day full of optimism and potential...and recently, heartburn and disappointment for the most devoted of Irish recruitniks who still flinch at the name Lorenzo Booker. Luckily, this year the Irish won a last-minute battle with Florida State for Booker's cousin, cornerback Terrail Lambert. Unfortunately, the overall grade for the class was notably average, and the Irish fell short at shoring up depth at key positions. For the second straight year, Notre Dame signed only two offensive lineman, and the class as a whole was one of the lowest ranked in recent history. It appeared that Willingham's strategy of doling out scholarship offers like golden tickets would leave the Irish empty-handed, with no backup plans once the A-list recruits turned down the Irish. And once again, Irish fans were left hoping that the class contained a few diamonds in the rough.

March

March started off an a sour note as defensive backs coach Trent Walters was hired by the Philadelphia Eagles as their new secondary coach. Walters was considered one of the best coaches on the staff, and many hoped that Willingham would take this opportunity to hire a top notch coach to assuage ND's perennial Achilles heel. As the month drew to a close, Willingham surprised the Irish faithful by tabbing Steven Wilks from Bowling Green. Wilks's inexperience raised more than a few eyebrows, but the players quickly warmed to Wilks during spring practice and some fans hoped that the young Wilks would be a shot in the arm for a staff that lacked many aggressive recruiters.

April

The entire offensive line would return in 2004 to protect rising sophomore Brady Quinn, and spring practices provided hope that the offense was starting to mature. As always, there were numerous positive practice reports, and the offense did not disappoint in the 75th Annual Blue and Gold Spring Game as the 1st-team offense won 35-7 in an impressive showing. More optimism appeared in the form of sophomore Tom Zbikowski, who had an interception and won the defensive MVP award. Three days later, the good news continued for the Irish program as six Notre Dame players were taken in the NFL Draft. Fan favorite Julius Jones just missed the first round (Bill Parcells selected him for the Dallas Cowboys early in the 2nd). Unfortunately Darrell Campbell, who suffered a knee injury while training for the draft, found himself undrafted by the time Mr. Irrelevant heard his name called.

May

After the draft, three more Irish players signed free agent contracts, giving Notre Dame nine players from the 5-7 team who made it to the NFL. Also in May was the groundbreaking for the new Don F. and Flora Guglielmino Family Athletics Center. When completed in mid 2005, the 95,840 square-foot, state-of-the-art Center will house all of the football offices and feature an expanded weight room, a larger film room, and a new locker room for practices.

June

In a fairly unprecedented move, AD Kevin White announced that the away game against BYU had been rescheduled to just before the Michigan game. This would give Willingham's team a much-needed opportunity to work out the kinks at game-speed before facing the Wolverines in South Bend. While Notre Dame historically has never backed down from tough opponents, some Irish fans felt that a slight "softening" of the schedule would be beneficial to Notre Dame's national championship hopes. Although not everyone bought this line of reasoning, most were happy that the wait until the kickoff of the 2004 season was reduced by one week.

July

A slow month in college football, fans on internet message boards wondered if this was the year that the Irish offense would finally click and become a force that didn't rely on the defense to win games. Announcements that Brady Quinn was named to the Davey O'Brien watch list and Anthony Fasano was selected to the Mackey Award watch list bolstered fan confidence and showed that even the media expected good things out of the Fighting Irish offense in 2004.

August

As fall practice started, early practice reports constantly trumpeted the good news that a crisp, efficient offense was really revving up. Eyewitness accounts of Travis Thomas, Ryan Grant, Darius Walker, and Justin Hoskins gave hope that the loss of Julius Jones would be minimized. Outside of the normal nicks and bruises, the Irish managed to avoid the injury bug, and as in every preseason, confidence was riding high. A rumored last-minute transfer by Tom Zbikowski that was quickly proven false was the only hiccup in a relatively smooth fall practice session. All eyes were on Willingham and the 2004 Irish in the all-important 3rd year of Willingham's tenure.

September

Ready and rarin' to go, and hoping to start the season off with a bang, the Irish instead shot themselves in the foot. ND stumbled to a 20-17 loss against BYU, and the optimism quickly turned to doubt. The program-low 11 yards rushing seemed impossible for a team returning an offensive line chock full of high school all-americans. With Ryan Grant out with a hamstring injury, Travis Thomas was summoned to carry the ball, and promptly coughed up three fumbles. Meanwhile, Darius Walker sat patiently on the bench. Depression hit Irish fans hard, many admitted they might be wrong about Willingham's chances for success, and most ND fans expected a second straight blowout loss to the Wolverines.

Next week however, in what became a hallmark of Willingham's tenure, a completely different Notre Dame team showed up and pushed around the Top 10 Michigan Wolverines, beating them 28-20. Notable in this game was the debut of freshman running back Darius Walker, who provided the offensive spark missing in the BYU game. Walker rang up an impressive 115 yards and two touchdowns in 31 attempts in his first collegiate game. Emotions and expectations rose up again as the Irish played a great game, and the vaunted #3 jersey appeared to have found another worthy owner. Little did Irish fans know that the Michigan game would be the high water mark for Darius the rest of the season.

Under the lights in East Lansing, the Irish put away the Michigan State Spartans 31-24 in a game that ended up a lot closer than it should have been. Zbikowski had perhaps the play of the year on a stripped fumble returned for a touchdown, but after Willingham emerged from the bowels of MSU Stadium in the third quarter (was it a bathroom break, coach? "None of your business", replied Ty), the Spartans mounted a comeback that made more than a few Irish fans uncomfortable. The Irish hung on to win.

Closing out September, Willingham and the Irish impressed ND fans and members of the Husky athletic department with a very convincing win over hapless Washington 38-3.

October

The image “http://graphics.fansonly.com/photos/schools/pur/sports/m-footbl/auto_action/a-orton090702.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.Purdue came into Notre Dame Stadium looking for their first win since 1974 and unfortunately, they had no trouble getting it. ND continued its recent trend of enhancing the Heisman hopes of opposing QB's as Kyle Orton looked unstoppable in the 41-16 romp. The game also added another disconcerting blowout loss to Willingham's ledger -- another 25-point home loss and shaky secondary play brought out a few more calls for Willingham's job as the Irish failed to show much improvement from the first game of the year.

Facing Willingham's former employer the next week, the Fighting Irish became the second D-1 football team to reach 800 victories, but still needed to bat down a pass in the end zone to secure the 23-15 win over the Cardinal.

The Irish then cracked the Top 25 with a 27-9 victory over Navy. But another speed bump came in the form of the Boston College, where for the second straight year Notre Dame scored the same number of touchdowns and field goals as the Eagles, but lousy second-half defense and frustrating miscues on PAT attempts left the Irish short on the scoreboard 24-23.

November

Consistent only in their inconsistency, the Irish followed up the loss to the Eagles with an upset of #9 Tenneessee 17-13 in Knoxville, and the questions continued: how could the Irish could defeat The image “http://graphics.fansonly.com/photos/schools/nd/galleries/m-footbl-110604/tenn-clausen.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.top-10 teams like the Volunteers and Wolverines yet stumble to the likes of BYU?

Again the roller coaster 2004 season continued when Notre Dame fell in the closing seconds to Pittsburgh 41-38 and Pitt QB Tyler Palko set a Notre Dame stadium record by throwing for five touchdowns against the Irish in a game.

Not to be outdone, Matt Leinart threw for five touchdowns of his own as the Irish lost to USC by 31 points for the third straight year 41-10 and cemented Leinart's shot at the Heisman Trophy. And while most Fighting Irish fans didn't expect a victory over the high flying Trojans, many could do nothing but shake their heads in disgust. As they had done the previous two meetings with USC, the Irish had early success on offense, but were unable to counter any of the defensive adjustments by the Trojans, and were ultimately overwhelmed.

The regular season was now over and Willingham's Irish stood at a decidedly average 6-5. Hoping to end the season on a good note, the Irish accepted a bid to play in the Insight.com bowl against the Oregon State Beavers. Not thrilled that Notre Dame accepted the bowl bid, Irish fans resigned themselves to playing in a subpar bowl and turned to recruiting for any good news. But on the last day in November, something happened that hardly anyone had expected: Tyrone Willingham was fired.

December

The final month of 2004 started in disarray as the Fighting Irish found themselves without a head coach and the Football Banquet and accompanying recruiting trip weekend were abruptly cancelled. Notre Dame message boards were flooded with rumors, half-truths, and wild accusations about how the firing transpired and who the next coach would be. The immediate choice seemed to be Utah coach Urban Meyer. Notre Dame officials flew out to Utah to close the deal with the former ND assistant only to find that he was further along in negotiations with Florida than anyone under the Dome realized, and Meyer rebuffed the Irish. The search quickly went underground while the media attacked the decision to fire Willingham and stoked the rumor mill with new coaching names released on almost an hourly basis. Finally, after 13 long days, Notre Dame officially introduced Charlie Weis as the 28th Head Coach of the Notre Dame Fighting Irish.

While perhaps unknown to many Irish fans at the beginning of the search, Weis's NFL accomplishments and Notre Dame diploma gave cause for new hope. After a stirring press conference brimming with confidence, Weis immediately set out hiring a coaching staff and picking up the recruiting baton where Willingham's staff had left off. Weis shored up Irish-committed players' confidence and aggressively pursued assorted longshots, and inspired Irish fans who had been used to the low-key Willingham approach to recruiting.

Meanwhile, Willingham's assistants stayed at Notre Dame to coach the Irish players for the upcoming Insight.com bowl while Willingham returned to the Pac-10 as the new coach of the Washington Huskies.

As the month and year came to an end, no new assistant coaches had been officially announced and the Irish traveled to Phoenix to play the OSU Beavers in an indoor baseball stadium. Staying true to their Willingham-inspired form, the Irish appeared unfocused and inconsistent, and dropped yet another game 38-21 to finish the 2004 season a lackluster 6-6.

Wrap-up

It's been quite a year. Yet despite the disappointing season, Irish fans everywhere seem optimisic on the future. 2004 left us breathless and exasperated (and ultimately shocked and surprised) but as 2005 begins, Notre Dame faces a fresh start, and Charlie Weis offers much hope for Irish football.

Here's to the new coach, the new attitude, and the New Year. Cheers.

Closing the Books on Willingham | by Sean

Before I get going, I have a trivia question. As we all know, Oklahoma (coached by Bob Stoops) and USC (coached by Pete Carroll) face off in the Orange Bowl on Tuesday night for the national championship. Can you name the only head coach who has an undefeated record head-to-head against both Stoops and Carroll? (Answer below).

Now, a few thoughts as I sit here watching the Gator Bowl and wondering just how bad a Bill Diedrick-run offense with Chris Rix at quarterback would be...

First, regarding the game on Tuesday night. The players and coaches had told us all for the last two weeks how they were going to use the Insight Bowl to conjure a fitting tribute to their departed leader, Tyrone Willingham. And after watching four hours of predictable play calling, uninspired blocking, bubble screens on 3rd and 20, and severely charred Notre Dame defensive backs, I have two words - MISSION ACCOMPLISHED.

I mean, is there a more appropriate way to close the books on the Tyrone Willingham Era than a double digit loss to a mid-level Pac 10 school on national television in which the Notre Dame secondary gives up 350 yards and four touchdowns? The only thing missing was Willingham himself after the game giving us his usual cryptic answers to very direct questions, and telling us how proud he is that the team improved over last year's 5-7 season.

Is this what rock bottom feels like? Funny how the Willingham apologists have clamed up. Mark May, Rod Gilmore, now do you see? I think the most frustrating part in this whole ordeal has been recent Notre Dame legends like Rocket Ismail, Aaron Taylor, and Chris Zorich actually taking up for Tyrone Willingham. I mean, would any of them have stood for the underachievement marked by this regime? Seriously, I think Zorich would have dismembered somebody after the Michigan game in 2003.

And while last night's game I'm sure ran the gamut of emotions for all of the players and coaches involved, when the clock finally struck 0:00 at the BOB on Tuesday night (yes, I stayed up until the bitter end), as a fan and alum to me it felt great, like there was a purging going on. Frankly, watching this coaching staff leave the field, I could hardly contain my joy. I wasn't watching the end of the 2004 campaign, I was watching the beginning of a better life for all of us. The outcome of the game was secondary. To me, I just couldn't wait for it to end, win or lose. Time to turn the page....

Along those lines, as I endured sixty minutes of Baer-ball the other night, I started to jot down a short list of things I won't miss from the Ty Willingham Era:

Fixation on Grant. Let me preface what I am about to say by acknowledging that Ryan Grant, by all accounts, is a great kid and a solid leader and I have nothing but respect for him as a Notre Dame student and person. He's played hurt, he's played hard. But the fact that he continued to get as many touches as Darius Walker did late in the season was baffling. Again, not to bash, but please tell me one facet of the tailback position at which Ryan Grant is even slightly above average. From a speed standpoint, he makes Lee Becton look like Rocket Ismail. He is about as elusive as the Washington Monument, which would be fine if it took more than a strong sneeze to knock him off his feet. In 2002, I understood Grant getting the bulk of the carries, since the only other options were Marcus Wilson (and his stellar 1.4 yards per carry) and Rashon Powers-Neal (who was 5 months away from becoming an undersized fullback). But in 2003, when it took Willingham five games to figure out what the rest of us figured out in five minutes - that Julius Jones should be the starting tailback - and in 2004, when a gamebreaker like Walker would get fewer touches than Grant, that was enough for me. There is a new stat that has become trendy the last few years - YAC (Yards After Contact). Grant might be the first player in history to accumulate negative YAC. Seriously.

The Swinging Gate. Or the Picket Fence, or the Hot Tin Roof, or whatever that silly looking formation we run on extra points is called. Seriously, what is the purpose of that? I know there has to be a reason we do it, but since (a) I've never seen us do anything except proceed to kick the ball through the uprights (most of the time) after scrambling from the Picket Gated Roof into PAT formation, and (b) I've never seen USC, Oklahoma, LSU, Auburn, or any of the, you know, GOOD teams use this, do we really need to have this thing in our arsenal? Riddle me this. Before we run out there to kick the PAT, does the Irish coaching staff have an equivalent to Dennis Hopper from "Hoosiers" yelling at the kick team to "not get caught watching the paint dry"? Maybe they'd have been better off using the time spent perfecting the Swinging Picket Fence on other things like...oh, I don't know, punt coverage. Seriously, I know I'm nitpicking and semi-clowning around, but at the risk of sounding juvenile, the Swinging Gate is stupid.

Bill Diedrick's "System". What does it say about our offensive coordinator when my 7-year old son is predicting the bubble screen on 3rd and 20 in the first quarter? Frankly, it probably doesn't say anything that hasn't already been said for the last two years. Diedrick is brutal. This offense that was supposed to be the staple of the "Ty Willingham as Head Coach" package turned out to be one big, predictable turd. And I don't expect many to be able to relate to the venom I am about to spew because it involves the last eight minutes of the Insight Bowl, and I'm sure most sane people were either sleeping or had switched over to a movie at that point, but Diedrick was absolutely clueless. At that point it was 31-14 with around eight minutes to go, and Notre Dame still had a puncher's chance to get back into it with a quick strike. So instead of going to a shotgun, hurry-up offense, Diedrick decides the best way to get back into it is to huddle up and take the full 25 seconds in between handoffs to Ryan Grant. On the first play, Grant tripped over the 25 yard line, and on the next handoff, I think snipers shot him in the left leg because he went down without an OSU defender touching him. Even Mike Gottfried, who sounded like he had a cooler full of Miller Lite in the press box, was wondering why Notre Dame wasn't moving with more of a sense of urgency. Go ahead and toss Diedrick on top of Rogers and Colletto in the scrap pile of former Notre Dame offensive coordinators. Good riddance.

The rest of the coaching staff. Thanks for coming, gentlemen. I will miss none of you. Seriously, go to und.com sometime and check out the bios on this crew. First, none of them have ties to Notre Dame. Second, most of them were just brought over mindlessly by Willingham from Stanford in 2002 without any regard to what recruiting outside of the Pac-10 might entail. Finally, by all accounts, this group was entirely ill-equipped to sell Notre Dame to young kids in today's aggressive recruiting environment, like having a bunch of Hyundai salesmen taking over a Porsche dealership. Part of being a great leader is surrounding yourself with a good support staff. Weis is assembling a "dream team" staff that will include some huge names on the recruiting circuit - Haywood, Ianello, etc. Willingham's only hire in the last two years is a secondary coach (Wilks) whose last four stops were one year stints at Bowling Green, East Tennessee State, Appalachian State, and Illinois State. Is it any wonder that Notre Dame finished 118th out of 117 teams in pass defense this season?

And while we're on the topic of Willingham's coaching staff, thoughts on Kent Baer. First, all things considered, I think Baer did about as commendable a job as one could expect in taking over the reins for the Insight Bowl. Unlike other members of the staff, he went about his business without using the last four weeks to bemoan the fate of Tyrone Willingham. It was a baptism by fire under bizarre circumstances, to say the least. That said, any Division 1-A athletics director watching that game that ever had Kent Baer on their theoretical "potential head coach" short list probably scratched him off immediately after his halftime interview with Erin Andrews. Did you see him? Oh my God, he looked completely baffled and overwhelmed. His eyes were darting around like they were chasing a strobe light as his brain was furiously cobbling together canned answers to Andrews' questions. Not a good performance. Decent coordinator, good man, mesmerized interim head coach.

In closing, kudos to a couple of players. First, Brady Quinn. I am giddy to see what this kid with all of his talent is going to do under Weis' tutelage. I think it's safe to say now, three years in, that the ineptitude of the Willingham/Diedrick offense has more to do with the guys designing it than the guys running it. I am excited for the future with Quinn for the next two years. For the last two years, the kid has taken more punishing hits in the pocket than any college quarterback I can remember and, without fail, he always picked himself back up. Just a tough SOB.

Finally, Carlyle Holiday. He came in as a highly touted option quarterback, endured a coaching change, and didn't complain at all when Diedrick and Willingham inexplicably tried to pound a square peg into a round hole by putting him into a West Coast offense (seriously, would Charlie Weis in a million years ever do this?). When it all came collapsing on his head at the beginning of 2003, complete with "The Holiday is Over" t-shirts, his response was to smile and say "maybe I'll buy one". When they moved him to wide receiver later that season, he did so willingly. Anything to help the team. Week after week this season, it would have seemed the coaching staff should find a way to use him. Here you have a weapon, a guy who can run and throw, playing wide receiver. A reverse, maybe? An option pass? And week after week, he ran his ten patterns, blocked downfield, and returned his three or four punts. (They would eventually use their "secret weapon" - in typical Diedrick/Willingham fashion, on consecutive plays coming out of a timeout, when the entire USC defense could see it coming. Thanks for that, coach. Sheesh.) At the final pep rally, when they introduced the seniors and their parents, the ovation for Holiday was not only the loudest, but it was the only one where everybody stood. Fans, players, coaches. Everyone. Clearly, he had the love and respect of his teammates. Frankly, I would be surprised to see Carlyle Holiday on an NFL roster this time next year. Two years of Davie and three years of Willingham have stunted his growth as a player to say the least. But whatever he ends up doing, I'll be rooting for him.

TRIVIA ANSWER: Bob Davie is 1-0 against both Bob Stoops and Pete Carroll. At Notre Dame, Davie defeated each one in their respective first years at Oklahoma (1999) and USC (2001). That piece of trivia goes right alongside Willingham's 10-3 record in 2002 in the "first year of a coaching regime is not indicative of future results" category.

Now, time to flip the calendar over to 2005. Let the Weis Era begin.