SCOTUS strikes down EO, affirms birthright citizenship.
3 liberal justices, ACB, and the Chief Justice (who wrote the opinion) signed on to establish the majority.
I Like Beer concurred in judgement but dissented in part -- basically opining that the EO isn't in conflict with the 14th as written, but does violate the federal statutes that codified and established the parameters of how the 14th would be applied.
As expected, Thomas dissented along with Alito. A bit surprising that Gorsuch joined in the dissent, particularly given his history with Native American citizenship rulings ... I haven't read the dissent, though, to see what the crux of the argument is.
Complete thread:
- SCOTUS strikes down EO, affirms birthright citizenship. -
Savage,
2026-06-30, 07:36
- If HRC had won in 2016 -- - omahadomer, 2026-07-01, 16:22
- The Atlantic has a good writeup on the ramifications - Joe I, 2026-07-01, 07:47
- Brett Kavanaugh, living constitutionalist
-
Publicola,
2026-06-30, 12:14
- The language in parts of the 14th amendment - Bryan (IrishCavan), 2026-06-30, 10:45
- NPR says Alito is retiring, Court officials say no such news -
Savage,
2026-06-30, 08:01
- not retiring -
HumanRobot,
2026-06-30, 11:39
- Really? Taft?
-
Coach Gillespie,
2026-06-30, 11:54
- Really? Taft?
- NPR just retracted the story. -
oviedoirish,
2026-06-30, 09:31
- Ha, that nugget probably came from the Trump administration, -
Joe I,
2026-06-30, 10:11
- I'd assumed it was a leak check
-
Charles,
2026-06-30, 13:39
- Guaranteed
-
Bryan (IrishCavan),
2026-06-30, 11:19
- Alito and Thomas should definitely not retire - MattG, 2026-06-30, 12:12
- I'd assumed it was a leak check
- Ha, that nugget probably came from the Trump administration, -
Joe I,
2026-06-30, 10:11
- It makes my stomach churn to contemplate how likely - BillyGoat, 2026-06-30, 08:06
- not retiring -
HumanRobot,
2026-06-30, 11:39
- Pretty sure Kav was the one during oral argument who -
BillyGoat,
2026-06-30, 08:00
- The scary part to me -
Dallasdomer,
2026-06-30, 12:05
- If it were only "long-held meaning." 4 judges... - PMan, 2026-07-01, 08:17
- Actually 5.5 to 3.5. Plus you had to know Alito and Thomas -
NDinVA,
2026-06-30, 22:29
- Alito and Thomas aren’t even judges - MattG, 2026-07-01, 10:28
- The scary part to me -
Dallasdomer,
2026-06-30, 12:05